J O.
Yelp
It's hard to sum up Turl St Kitchen, because the menu changes every day, to accommodate fresh, seasonal, local ingredients. This is great, but means that many dishes are often hit-or-miss. The food style is very homey, and sometimes this ends up detracting from the good ingredients. Often the food can be rather bland and a bit of a mess, which can make the mains disappointing. This happens a bit too often, I'm afraid. The sides are usually good, but sometimes they can be way too salty or way too bland. It's very inconsistent (sensing a theme, here?). The desserts are usually fantastic. The service is also inconsistent - I've been seated and then waited 15 minutes just for someone to come over to take our beverage order (even after clearly staring in the direction of the point-of-sale system).
TSK is also a hang-out/tea-all-day kind of place, which means that it's open late and also between meal service. You can grab a chair in their comfortable sitting/living room and have some tea (usually quite good), a latte (decent), or a hot chocolate (appallingly terrible). I'm not sure if I've ever had such bitter, tasteless, flavorless hot chocolate in my life.
There is also a full bar, which gets rather busy in the evenings, but the atmosphere is a bit boring for a bar. The sitting room is a nice place to hang out and relax, and they do offer free Wi-Fi. The dining room is quaint, comfortable, and a nice place to be, even between meal times.
I've had some delicious meals at TSK, and I've had some very disappointing meals at TSK. When you change your menu twice a day, this is to be expected, but it's rather unfortunate, as there are some great dishes on the menu, from time to time. It's also not particularly cheap (roughly £30 for dinner for two). Getting a table for dinner on a Thursday-Saturday night almost always requires a booking in advance, which involves calling the restaurant and leaving a message, and then receiving a call-back to confirm - this system is very annoying.
If the food and service were more consistent, and the prices were a little lower (or the food were better overall), it would be a four-star place. As it is, however, I don't see anything overwhelmingly special about this place. It's just "OK".