Tuscany Italian Market & Catering

Went to Tuscany Italian Deli today for lunch and it was honestly really good. I had the Chicken Parm Vodka Hero, and it was awesome. The chicken was tender and juicy, and the vodka sauce was creamy and flavorful. The sandwich was balanced and the roll was perfect—not too soft, not too hard, just right. I also grabbed a couple of pastries on the way out, and they were delicious. Fresh and satisfying without being overly sweet—definitely worth trying. They mentioned they do a customer appreciation event every month, which sounds cool. I’m definitely going to check that out next time. If you’re in the area and looking for a good sandwich (or a treat), Tuscany’s worth stopping by. I’ll definitely be back.

They made a custom Italian Cream cake for a birthday party. It was amazing! Very delicious. Can't wait until our next event. I think we will try the lemon cake. :)

I’ve visited this Italian deli twice so far and ordered the meatball Parmigiana hero both times. On my first visit, the sandwich was generously filled and tasted great — definitely hit the spot, and I was charged the correct price as posted. On my second visit, the sandwich wasn’t quite as stuffed as the first time, and I noticed I was charged $1 more than the listed price for the same item, so instead of paying $12.75+ tax I was charge $13.75+ tax. Overall, I’m not happy about my second visit here and I will go to Mario’s Meat market moving forward.

I was ecstatic to find Tuscany Italian Market. Coming from southeast Michigan there are Italian markets every two miles. Here in Southwest Florida they are non existent. I am very surprised at the authenticity of the food. Do yourself a favor and stop by, their prepared food is outstanding. You won’t be disappointed.

We cannot thank Tuscany Italian Market enough for making our wedding celebration even more unforgettable! We started going to Tuscany almost weekly after tasting their delicious food at one of our FMCC church events, and we knew right away that they would be our caterers of choice for our Italian-themed wedding. They absolutely nailed the custom charcuterie board, which was stunning and delicious. Both Anthonys were so incredibly helpful from the very start, guiding us through the process and bringing our wedding menu to life. They even went the extra mile by setting aside a few bottles of our favorite wine to make sure we had them for our special day! I wish we had taken photos of the dinner, but everyone was so excited to dig in! We had caesar salad, eggplant rollatini, lasagna, chicken piccata, St. Joseph's pasta, asparagus, and their amazing cannolis for dessert. The food was absolutely delicious, and it was such a hit with all of our guests. Thank you, Anthonys and team, from the bottom of our full, happy hearts. You helped make our wedding day even more special, and we are forever grateful for your amazing food and exceptional service. God bless, Erin & John

We bought the vodka sauce and meatballs in a red sauce. First off the meatball’s were very bland tasting and made so compacted that we had to microwave them after we cooked them in the sauce to serve them hot on the plate. The sauce was also very bland tasting. We tried doctoring it up but it’s just not worth the money spent to have to give it flavor. After wasting money on this pricey food we will not be going back. Very disappointed to say the least

I love everything about this Market. As a full blood Italian it has to be good to say that! The homemade Ravioli are outstanding, the fresh and aged meat outstanding and don't get me started on the delicious grilled shrimp WOW! This is a new small business so PLEASE go and support them. You deserve to eat like this.

1st time here, now my go to place Homemade Ricotta cheese is fabulous Everything I bought was over and beyond amazing Italian hot sausage and the pastries are spot on

Ordered Large orders from the catering menu,Chicken Piccata,Chicken Parm,and Baked Ziti.....was fantastic...Their food is delicious..Thank you Tuscany,everyone enjoyed it very much.

Their selection and quality of meats is over the top. They also have Italian style prepared food, haven't found a looser yet. Service is also exemplary. Everyone is engaged and happy and you're treated like you mean everything to them. The ambiance is truly little Italy, in my opinion. The owner is often present and is willing to talk to you.

What a great place! I went in a little too close to closing and was welcomed like they had just opened. They took time and explained different options then made me one of the best sandwiches I've had in a long time. You can easily get two meals out of one sandwich. The food is fresh and delicious. Staff is friendly and helpful. Definitely recommend this place.

Great food, quick service, and great prices. We love the baked goods (especially the armaretti cookies and bread pudding), fresh mozzarella, and premade Strombolis. We have tried a bunch of items from this market, it's all delicious. It's a small Italian market, but lots of options. Totally recommend!

So freaking good! Had The Godfather and the Toscana salad. Amazing! Both were extremely well balanced. The big plus about the sandwich was the roll, which was exceptional, but a close second was that there was absolutely zero sinuey meat in it. And the sundried tomatoes in the salad were exceptional. The provolone was also top notch. Don't dunk the salad; pour it all over. Much better that way.

Second time at this lovely Italian Market and take out Restaurant. Beautiful patio with seating to enjoy eating in the best Florida weather. Today is customer appreciation day with 20% off everything! Lots of free samples, pizza, wine and pastry! Barbecue hamburgers too! Live entertainment with an entertainer singing in Italian! Perfect for this girl who came from Bensonhurst in Brooklyn. It was a Jewish/Italian neighborhood and I grew up by Four Star Ravioli as well as by a Kosher Delis! Lol! Dave had a great time shopping while I enjoyed the entertainment. Thank you Tuscany for your Customer Appreciation Day!

This client appreciation Day. Is 5 star. 20% off WOW. KNOWLEDGEABLE & service oriented staff Everything a home chef needs to look good. Look at deli cooked line. Our 2nd trip in two weeks

Food quality is good but there is too much available. Service is alway pleasant and helpful.,I think they have too much verity and often popular items are not available.Certainly they should limit how much is available. On many occasion I visit and what I'm looking for is unavailable., I think it's best to reduce inventory to your most popular products.The shop is always clean and well set up.

Excellent Italian Market. Many great foods to chose from and all look delicious. I got the Godfather Sub and asked for Mortadella to be added, it was superb. Roll was a little dense, but super fresh and crusty. Meats weee sliced paper thin and veggies were fresh. Service was great and it is a very clean store with many selections. There is outside seating too.

Not sure why they say they are open until 3:00 pm on Sundays. I've been multiple times between 2:00 and 2:15 and they've put away the meat; obviously more eager to get home than earn my money. I just spend my $150 down the street.

When you walk into this place, it is just like being back in the Bronx. They have delicious pastries and bakery items. The butcher recommended a truly wonderful NY strip steak that was like "buttah". You can find authentic Italian groceries and other item here. Stop by for a look around and try the tiramisu and cannoli's.

Food and Service was just like you were back in Italy! Great that you can eat right there on the porch too...

3/15/2025 I had three of my locations catered by Tuscany Italian Market. I had employee appreciation day. We fed about 125 people. I ordered 6' hero's from chicken Parmesan, chicken with broccoli rabe fresh mozzarella, American style, caprese salad, Caesar salad, Greek platter , 125 cannoli. There wasn't one complaint about the food. I wish I had taken photos of the food, but it was amazing. I will most definitely cater from them again. Ask for Anthony he was great to deal with. A side note, I get lunch from them at least weekly.

This place has the best Stromboli ever! Everything is made fresh and delicious don't leave without getting the Lobster Tail pastry and order extra napkins!

My favorite go to for an amazing sandwich. I always get the Godfather. Wish I took a picture but ate it! Every item is freshly sliced to order. Service is impeccable. I found another gem in their salads. Unforgettable. I will see them very soon!

Food was delicious , a little salty though But very tasty and great service Will be back

best in the area. Imported ingredients and homemade dishes. 3 foot subs are outstanding and stuffed with good stuff, can never get enough of cherry peppers stuffed with feta. The desserts are divine. No other Italian Store comes close to this place.

Amazingly delicious, everything we bought!!! The Godfather Hero, Sausage and Pepper Roll, Antipasta, Potatoe Rolls, and Cheesy Rice Balls. Keep up the great work!!!!

Super helpful and friendly staff. Authentic Sicilian/Italian market. I have made this my go to for traditional Italian/Sicilian food.

Authentic Italian experience - from the owners to their recipes. Catering, sandwiches, atmosphere are not to be missed if you're in SWFL.

We hired Tuscany to cater. It was a terrible experience. Food delivered and left on my counter and was left cold. It sat for two hours before someone showed up and we had to heat food. I had a tough piece of well done cold meat and cold potatoes( ordered Idaho and was given smashed cold redskin) Food left out almost 4 hours so was not suitable to keep. We spent a lot of money and wasn't worth it. I am A cook and was embarrassed to serve to my guests. I can cook a perfect warm prime rib and have the correct potatoes warm for a whole lot less and will taste 5 times better. Truly a disappointment.

Excellent variety. All Food appeared fresh and appetizing Good service and cleanliness

Just like the North End in Boston ! Sandwiches sliced to order super fresh! Bread was to die for! Pastries looked good as well. Fresh Mozzarella yummy Service was good!

this Italian market! From prepared foods to pizza and fresh butcher cut items to cook at home. Can't go wrong with their wine selection or cured olives either.

We are lucky to have this true Italian market. The sausage is amazing. I used to buy it at Mario's. The rice balls are also fantastic. Their ground sirloin is fresh and delicious. If you came from up north and looking for an Italian market, this is it. ​

Amazing food coupled with outstanding service. I only travel to Florida a few times per year and this place is always my first stop. The eggplant caponata is the best I've had. Please support this local gem!

Do not waste your time, if you would like to get treated like shit by the bald guy who is in the deli then this is your spot. Customer service is a standard at Italian delis, go to Mario's around the corner for a proper experience. Bald guy was hurrying me to order and was rude, btw it was only me at his shop....no wonder why Mario's is always full with customers.

Went to Tuscany Italian Market & Catering in Fort Myers, FL today. It's a fairly new place and I was really impressed. I had tilapia with bruschetta on top for lunch. They heat things up and you can eat outside. Of course I had to buy a Napoleon for dessert. The staff was wonderful. Wish I could've posted more pictures because there is so much more in the store.

Excellent in every aspect!! Amazing food and desserts. Even great priced wines!!! The owners who all work there , make you feel welcome and treat you like family!!

This is a SWFL hidden gem and it does not get more authentic Italian than this place! You can trust that anything you get there will be amazing, friendly staff and quick service, would give it 10 stars if I could!

My family and I can't recommend this market enough. We walked in and instantly fell in-love. Everything is made fresh in-house: from the bakery, to the salads, and all of the sausages and cured meats! All of the staff was extremely friendly and willing to answer questions and chat - outstanding customer service. We purchased a variety of sausages/meat, bakery items and some salads and everything was to die for (coming from a fellow Italian family)! The fennel sausages and the cheese and parsley chevalatta was so beyond delicious - I don't think my dad will shop for sausage anywhere else after this! I cant recommend this market enough to the community and love this family-owned business.

Bought 2 Lbs. Fennel sausage this week and the salt content was way way Too high. That's all you taste is salt. Won't be buying any sausage there in the future.

I was there a long time ago and found everything just fine. They offered me some samples of their food which was very good. I purchased some pastries and Ice cream Italian style.

Service is friendly and funny they all speak Italian and love what they do all were helpful and fun will be back

Staff wasn't overly friendly, standing around behind the counter and would make customers go get a number to be served even if no one else was in line. Food was ok, sandwiches very skimpy but over priced. Mario's Meat Market much better.

This place has issues.On my first trip I bought a couple of pounds of cookies. they over charged me $1.00 a pound on the cookies and some were stale. Total over charge $4.00 On the second trip The premade items were ok at best .This is me, form your own opinion here. On the third trip I walked out. 8 or 9 people working and no one wants to be bothered. On the fourth trip I want to get some sausage. I buy 4 different kinds there are all $6.99@lb except 1 which was $7.99@lbs. He charged me $7.99 a pound for all of them. Todays overcharge $5.00 Tonight My wife says the hot sausage smells a little sour. I told her. Shady butchers often mix old spoiled meat in with the good meat when grinding (sausage, meatballs, etc.) This kind of thing works best with the hot sausage like I bought. I am done with this place But If you chose to try for yourself watch everything very closely

Wow, the guy inside was extremely rude. I took a customer from my work that was asking about an Italian shop. The doors were open at 8:15 in the morning I was assuming they were open I walked inside in the gentlemen, working the counter screamed at us to get outside that they were closed, that is no way to treat people I'm not too sure if his English wasn't best, but he was extremely rude. Raising his voice and using hand gestures ? For zero reason to the point where I had to leave and I never plan on coming back After being a solid customer for a while. I was trying to help a small business pick up some customers. Wow did I make a mistake? You're better off going to the next-door Publix or even make the trip to Mario's meat market you don't wanna deal with people

We loved it! It was very clean items were very well presented their cannolis that they had samples made us buy some they were that good prices were good parking lot we just loved it we came from Naples because we had heard about it we are originally from Chicago and miss real Italian cold cuts and different delicacies they definitely have it we told a few friends and I'm sure they'll love it also.

Standing at the counter to check out and the cashier literally ignored me and waited on two people who came up after me. You just lost what would've been a loyal customer. I will not recommend this place to anyone.

Beautiful selections of Italian and American prepared foods. Great selection of cheeses and olives. Homemade ricotta and pasta. Large variety of salads and breads, pastries and desserts, wine and butcher shop all in one. The preparation and quality of the food is top notch.

Delicious homemade Italian food and enormous variety of prepared food. Love the ricotta and lasagna. Reminds me of Italian deli in NY.

Best italian market !!! EVERYTHING IS SO FRESH! The workers treated me with such kindness and the place is beautiful!

Wow! What a pleasant surprise! Excellent food, selection and service. We had a meatball sub, substituted ricotta for parmigiana cheese, excellent. Wife had the Godfather sub, was super as well. Loaded up on the desserts, plenty to choose from. So excited about having another real Italian market on this side of Ft Myers. Some seating outside. Excellent place, will be regulars. Highly recommend.

Do yourself a favor and get over to this location! Their selection of proper Italian specialty items is amazing and decently priced compared to local grocery, Mario's, and European grocery. Their bread (get there early) is perfection. Meat selection limited, but what they do have is exceptional and at market price. We have purchased the NY Strip & handmade sausages several times when guests arrive & thus far it has been absolutely the best. My mouth is watering thinking about it. Their bakery item selection is fantastic, splurge and get the large lobster tail, you can't go wrong. My fave are the Italian butter cookies, nostalgic pick on my part. Wine selection slightly above average, sparkling water and other cold items great selection. This store is well organized & very clean. The handmade mozzarella is delicious and like eating a cloud! We have not yet tried all their offering from the deli counter, but plan to soon when guest start back coming through. They have everything from stuffed meatballs, lasagna, cold past dishes too many to list, seafood pasta items and much more. However, if everything I referenced isn't enough of reason to try this place out, I have literally saved the absolute best for last...They have an entire menu of cold & hot deli sandwiches made to order for $13 bucks with only fresh ingredients. We get them at least twice a week and if that wasn't enough of an endorsement, these sandwiches are huge, and my husband and I must split it! So, lunch for two for $13 bucks! I rarely write reviews, but this place has earned it over and over with me! The only thing that would make this location any better, if they started carrying fresh produce, fingers crossed they will eventually since they are so new to the area.

We were so excited about this new market. First let me start by saying they were not very friendly at all. If I were just starting a new business, I would be way more pleasant and talkative than any of them were, and the store was not busy at the time. We purchased Italian pastries and bread. The cannoli(s) were soggy as all get out. Any Italian knows that you fill them as you sell them. The shells were so soggy we threw them away. We also bought the Saint Joseph's pastries and asked for the ricotta filled and ended up with the cream filled. The Limoncelli cake was meh. We also (which I was so excited about and thought about it for days) purchased the ciccioli bread. It was far from fresh as I imagined it would be and it lacked the peppery taste to it, but it did have plenty of pork in it. It was displayed out on a table with no heat lamps to at least provide some warmth to it so it can be eaten right away, it was also braided, not the traditional circle shape, which was fine with us. We did try to revive it (on the same day we bought it) in the oven, but it just wasn't good. We did eat it some of it dipped in olive oil, but we were very disappointed. I know we will not return there for any reason. I really wanted to love this place, and probably could have if the bakery items were fresh.