Tutto Caffé

I recently visited Tutto and was delighted by the experience. This charming café has a lovely ambiance that makes it a perfect spot for enjoying a coffee and a sweet treat. The standout for me was the almond flour chocolate cake—rich, moist, and simply delicious. It paired perfectly with their excellent coffee, which was brewed to perfection. The café boasts a beautiful patio that’s ideal for outdoor seating when the weather is nice. Even if you end up sitting inside, the cozy, inviting atmosphere makes for a pleasant visit. The staff were friendly and knowledgeable, with a special shout-out to the girl who served me—she was exceptionally helpful in explaining their pastry menu. Overall, Tutto is a delightful place to unwind with a great cup of coffee and a tasty treat. I highly recommend it to anyone looking for a cozy, welcoming café experience.

Tutto Caffé is a fantastic pub that I absolutely loved from the moment I stepped inside! The coffee is simply amazing, easily one of the best I’ve ever had. The staff is super friendly, making you feel welcome and at home from the get-go. The ambiance is cozy and inviting, perfect for relaxing or catching up with friends. This was my first time here, and I honestly wish I had a place like this closer to home. The dessert was incredible too – a perfect way to end the experience. I will definitely be back whenever I get the chance!

The staff were very polite and friendly. The service was excellent, and I was very impressed. The food was delicious. Great vibes and perfect for photos. I will definitely come back again!

Tutto cafe is one of our favorite spots in East Hampton! Whether it’s for a quick coffee and some cookies or pastries if we’re on the go, or for a mid afternoon cocktail and a light lunch, we always make it a point to stop by when in the area. Their cocktails are some of the best in the area. Their Paloma is my favorite, absolutely refreshing and well balanced. Their pinsa, or Roman style pizza, is always good. We especially loved their autumn one they had last fall.. Hope to see it back. Their quinoa salad is absolutely delicious! Packed with great ingredients, it’s hearty yet refreshing and light. Service always friendly and quick.

Joana works like she owns the place! She highly cares about the customers, a very wonderful human being! Also , Great location and delicious food.

Lovely decor, clean, warm and welcoming. Staff was terrific. Flat white was excellent, great flavor and milk/coffee ratio. I was visiting EH so unaccustomed to jaw dropping prices, so I’m sorry, but $9 for a flat white and $6 for ice coffee is a little crazy. Otherwise a nice place.

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 5/5 “Hidden Gem on the Way to Montauk!” Every time we head out to Montauk, our first stop—without question—is always Tutto Caffè in East Hampton. It’s one of those rare places that instantly feels like a part of your tradition, even after just one visit. Tucked away from the more obvious main spots, this café truly feels like a hidden gem that more people should know about (but selfishly, we almost want to keep it to ourselves). The ambiance is simple yet elegant—cozy, welcoming, with a laid-back Hamptons charm. You can tell there’s thought behind everything, from the perfectly brewed coffee to the friendly and attentive staff. It’s the kind of place where you can sit outside and relax in the morning sun, or tuck into a warm corner and recharge before continuing your journey. We usually come for breakfast, and this time we ordered the avocado toast and sunny side up eggs. Both were absolutely delicious—fresh, beautifully plated, and packed with flavor. The only thing we noticed is that the portions are on the smaller side. Not a dealbreaker at all, especially considering the quality, but we do wish they were just a little more generous, especially after a long drive. One suggestion: it would be amazing to see an Eggs Benedict option on the menu one day. A classic like that would be a perfect fit here, and we’d be the first to order it! Overall, Tutto Caffè continues to be one of our favorite stops along the way to Montauk. Great coffee, great food, great people—and an atmosphere that makes you want to linger a little longer. Highly recommended!

Espresso had great balance and they were using a distribution tool for puck prep 👌. Seemed like a longer ratio pull — slightly watery (1:2.5-3?) and lacking any strong aromas (possibly older beans?) but well extracted overall. ☕️

What a beautiful cafe! I stopped in here on a Sunday morning. Although quite busy, it was totally worth it. I ordered a shakerato, cream croissant, and a nutella cookie. The pastries were to die for ... so fresh. The croissant was flaky and soft, and the cookie melted in my mouth. The shakerato was delicious, too.

Senza dubbio, questo è il caffè più confortevole e rilassante di East Hampton, New York. Se siete alla ricerca di un posto dove studiare o leggere un giornale la mattina presto, allora questo è il posto giusto. Un'amica di mia madre sulla destra mi ha consigliato di venire qui perché amo, amo e sono innamorata della cucina e delle tradizioni italiane. Spero che i miei modi di imparare la lingua italiana continuino mentre continuo a mangiare tutti i deliziosi pasticcini che trovo lì - haha, adoro i vostri tiramisù ragazzi! È stato bella. As for the service, we had no issues whatsoever. The cashier and staff were very well mannered, polite, and you can feel the warmth around them. Thank you for your service. Ciao a tutti

If you wish to be ignored and have the waitress look annoyed you are seated I highly recommend going here. If not stay away. We left so can't say anything about the food or drinks.

Lovely cafe in EH - it was closing when I went there so I didn't get a chance to eat here but I'll definitely do so in the near future - many options for vegetarians

Really excited to have a little breakfast and a cappuccino in the Hamptons! Never been before, love the weather and the vibe...then Tutto's. Cute little place with a very nice outdoor area, lots of rosemary..so nice. Ordered the sunny side eggs with tomato and avocado with the smoked salmon. Eggs were WAY overdone and never saw a bit of butter or any seasoning for that matter. But the cappuccino would be brilliant, right? No. Yuck. Sorry. Not worth the money either.

This is a great new addition to East Hampton life. Friendly, warm staff who seem to genuinely appreciate your business. Also, first rate coffee, food, and drinks at more reasonable prices than that other place, lol. You might see movie stars but don't worry..if you don't, the staff all look like they're young stars so even though the place is tucked into an alley it's easy to imagine that you are somewhere in Europe or Hollywood....or, the Hamptons lol.

Not from the area just needed to grab a drink, comfy environment and great service, coffee was tasty

Despicable and rude service by the hostess in the black dress today. I got 2 croissants and a coffee and sat down with my 3 young kids. The hostess was walking around serving people water. I asked her if we could get some water for our table. She refused to bring us water saying "you did take away and not table service so I will not be getting you any water." I paid $40 for 2 croissants and a coffee but couldn't even get water - disgusted by the service. Never have I experienced this nonsense in the area.

Caffe Tutto is a great cafe. The atmosphere is very nice. Reminiscent of cafes in Florence. The coffee is excellent as well as there sweets. Today I had a Negroni. I am very partial to Negronis as I had them growing up. It is a very wonderful cocktail not to sweet and delicious with a hint of orange. I must say their Negroni was the best I've ever had. It made my afternoon.

Unfortunately we went there today, and a 7 $ cappuccino was serves in a paper cup because "there are too many people in the summer, and we can't wash the cups". Terrible. Cappuccino was very sour.

Service was terrible. Food was even worse. Overall, dogshit experience. Never coming back.