Tutto Carne

Service was excellent. The mussels were outstanding, and the sauce was spot on. The side of cacio e pepe was very close to what I had in Italy. Unfortunately, the steaks were a letdown. The cuts themselves were high quality, but they appeared to be cooked either sous vide with a quick sear or by a very slow reverse sear. The clues were the uniform edge to edge doneness and a very thin exterior crust. My preference is a medium-rare steak with a deep, flavorful sear, and that was missing. On the ribeye, the outer fat cap did not have enough time at high heat to render, so a large portion was unappealingly fatty. The steak was labeled as 60-day dry aged, but it did not show the robust, nutty dry-aged flavor I normally expect. At $240 for the ribeye, the value was poor. At this price point, I have been to other steakhouses that far surpass this experience for 1/3 the price. I would return for the mussels and pasta, but I would skip the steaks.

The service was incredible. I was with a large party and our server (I think his name was Mike) and the bartender tag teamed us and gave amazing recommendations, prompt service, and were both so accommodating for our group and catered to our dietary restrictions so well. The food was delicious! It was such a neat concept— they’ve really nailed the family style of restaurant dining and elevated it! Also, the details throughout the restaurant truly set this experience apart– the plates were just darling. Highly highly recommend and want to extend my gratitude to the entire staff for such a memorable and exceptional meal!

My kids and husband surprised me for Mother’s Day. This was our first visit. Such an amazing experience!! The food was so delicious, and the dessert was great as well. The service was beyond excellent!! I would give this ten stars!!

I’m not sure why this place is not getting more recognition? The food was great. The steaks were cooked perfectly to both me and my girlfriend’s liking while being seasoned well. The pasta was fresh and the sauce tasted authentic. The potatoes were crunchy on the outside and fluffy on the inside, seasoned to perfection. The cocktails were different but worked really well. The atmosphere was quaint and very welcoming. While the restaurant was small, I did not feel like we were super close to the tables next to us. This place is a hidden gem. I’m not sure why it is not getting more local praise. The only reason why I gave it 4/5 stars on service is because I was comparing it to the service of a Michelin star restaurant. By no means was the service bad. I highly recommend this place and cannot wait to go back.

I had an absolutely wonderful birthday dinner here with fantastic service from Marcus. Spencer helped too and was phenomenal. Drinks were amazing and food even better! Bone-in filet with 2 dipping sauces was incredible. Wife loved her pasta. Mussels were insanely delicious. What a great spot and thank you for a great dinner!!

Tutto Carne is walking distance from my home so I was anxious to check out a new neighborhood venue that was not typically Italian. The red wines by the glass selection was robust. The glassware was very elegant. The butter served with the bread was very tasty. I was especially interested in the appetizers as they featured a couple of my favorites. The steak tartare was excellent. The grated cheese on top was a bit surprising but very toothsome. I would definitely order this again. The sweetbreads were also delicious although a bit visually overpowered with the micro greens sprinkled on top. Well prepared and something that is not available at very many locations around the city. My server, Michael, was attentive, efficient and friendly. My appetite is not what it used to be in my youth. The two appetizers filled my up nicely. I love good steaks. Sometime I must skip my favorites and order one of their tempting meat offerings. The restaurant is, after all, named 'All Meat'.

We came to celebrate my birthday! The restaurant was a charming little spot with very dim lighting, creating a quiet and intimate atmosphere—perfect for a true date night dinner. It was our first time out since having our child. The staff was incredibly friendly and helpful from start to finish. Mason, our server, was one of the best I’ve ever had at any establishment. He guided us through the menu, offered great suggestions, and had enjoyable conversations with us. A manager checked in a couple of times and was also very helpful. The food was overall very good! While it wasn't the best meal of my life, I was very happy with all of our choices except the mushrooms. Our favorites were the wedge salad, chicken parmigiana, and Brussels sprouts. I ordered the 24 oz ribeye, and it was good. However, having lived in Oklahoma for nearly a decade, where one of the best steakhouses in the nation is located, I tend to compare steaks, especially when considering prices. To wrap up the night, they presented us with a thoughtful card and a mini bottle of champagne. Overall, it was a wonderful experience. It is on the pricier side, but definitely worth it for a special occasion.

Amazing restaurant, especially for happy hour. Received the best service I've ever gotten in Cleveland. Highly recommend all the cocktails, especially the cats meow. Really thoughtful and refined cocktail menu, and tasty chicken parm!

Amazing. The food, the service, everything! My husband & I came for a quick dinner before our grandson's baseball game & it did not disappoint. The bread service alone is worth the visit. Generous portions & the food was perfectly prepared. The bartender took care of us & she was perfect. Can't wait to go back.

I ate at Tutto Carne for a celebratory graduation dinner with my husband, mom, stepdad, and grandma. All of us were delighted with our service and food. They had an exceptional special at $40 for a bottle of nice champagne, which my husband and I split. Others in the group got a mocktail and a glass of red wine. We started with two orders of the "vegetable garden" which is a truly special dish composed of ricotta, pesto, and some magic served in a small terracotta pot and made to look like a small planting of carrots and radishes. It was so delicious that I would go back to eat just this dish over and over again. For meals, we split various cuts of steak and ordered several sides, including sweetbreads, mac and cheese, and brussels sprouts. The steaks were perfectly done and the table loved the sweetbreads. I thought the mac and cheese could've been creamier, but I'm just splitting hairs here - the meal was exceptional. The pricetag is in line with how good the meal is, making this a great date night or special occasion spot, but probably not an every day dinner. I can't wait for another special occasion to pop up so I have an excuse to come back here.

My boyfriend surprised me last night with a romantic/ intimate dinner date. As soon as we were greeted at the door by a nice gentleman that said "buona sera" I knew it was going to be a good experience. The man working at the door held the door open for us. I loved the environment of the wall decor the furniture etc. Our server, Mason and his trainee were so amazing. Mason is very well educated and carries himself like a true professional in the food industry he is very well educated on the food, all around we had such a good experience. The food was OUTSTANDING. We had the potatoes, asparagus and chatebrean steak. All grass feed meat. The cocktails were OUTSTANDING! We were too full for dessert but we will definitely be back soon. All around an unforgettable experience!

We had a memorable meal at Tutto Carne. The servers were friendly, available and knowledgeable. The room was warm and cozy. There was only one glitch. We were seated at a table where I faced a window. The sun was directly in my eyes and made me squint. The drapes didn't close and we had to have our table moved. We ate dinner at 7:15 and sunset wasn't until 9:00 so it would have been uncomfortable for almost 2 hours. It was better when we moved. The mussels were excellent and served with freshly made focaccia bread. I was impressed with the generous portion of anchovies that went with the caesar's salad. The steak was a perfect medium and the sides, mashed potatoes and creamed spinach were perfection. We enjoyed the donuts for dessert. It was surprising that the valet parking was only $5.00. We did tip them as well. All in all, a fun experience.

This place is our new favorite. Came out as a first date out post newborn and had an amazing time. Our waitress was so passionate about providing the best experience she really made it special. Not captured were the drinks. They all were delicious and well balanced.

Tutto Carne delivers a really nice mix of tasty food in a delightful setting, that is dark but romantic. From the team behind Giovanni's (one of my favorites and a guarantee of quality) and in the space previously held by Nora, which I also really like, Tutto Carne adds to the steakhouse options in Greater Cleveland that are worth exploring and one of the best dining options in Little Italy. The service was very friendly, the timing of the different dishes was a bit off, but would hope it was an isolated hiccup, and we will definitely return in the future.

I came to Tutto Carne for a Thursday dinner with my friend, my other friend, and my friend's mom. We had never been and were fairly unfamiliar with the menu, but excited to try this new Little Italy steakhouse! The restaurant is small but quite swanky and quirky. They have dark walls, mismatched plates, and a general vintage vibe - pretty perfect for a classy evening out in my opinion. Our waitress Hannah and Angela (perhaps the manager) were very helpful in talking us through the menu. It was pretty clear that customers before us had some confusion with how this restaurant operates, but they gave us a nice summary of what they recommended and how to order for our party of 4. My two friends each got a cocktail (The Merlin and The Girl with the Obstructed Vieux Tattoo) and they said that they were fine - a little on the sweet side for their preferences but okay, just not showstopping. They brought us bread from Fluffy Duck and butter with olive oil and I believe breadcrumbs and salt (?). My first bite was a LOT of salt which covered up the taste of the bread - every bite I took after was a bit more intentional and avoiding a lot of the garnish on the butter/olive oil improved the experience and I can confirm that the bread was good. For appetizers we got the Tiny Vegetable Garden, a caesar salad, and a wedge salad split for the table. We only got the salads because we were advised that 1 salad would not be enough. I think we would've been fine with just the wedge salad between the 4 of us because our goal was to try more of the entrees/sides. Only complaints on the salads were they were dripping in dressing, and it was a bit much for my taste. We LOVED the Tiny Vegetable Garden. Micro-turnips and carrots come in a terracotta pot with ricotta and "edible dirt" which is basically a seasoning blend, along with some bread. It was so unique and the edible dirt-ricotta blend was quite delicious, perfect with the vegetables and bread. There definitely could've been more vegetables in our terracotta pot given there was a healthy portion of ricotta and not much to eat it with, but overall an adorable start to our meal. For our mains, we split a 29 oz chateaubriand steak (they have a chalkboard with "large format steaks" and you can select a given cut/size for $5/oz that they slice and serve family style, with chateaubriand really being the only option with smaller sizes), spaghetti carbonara, gnocchi (ordered because Hannah and Angela spoke very highly of it and my friend's mom felt we needed to try it), pommes puree, and charred asparagus. I felt our meal was nicely balanced. The chateaubriand was incredibly tender and a great size for our party. The sides were a nice pairing - the asparagus was exactly what you expect and the pommes puree was nice and a little sweet which I thought would be offputting but I enjoyed. The pastas were great. The carbonara is a traditional carbonara without butter or cream but was still very buttery and creamy, with nice quality guanciale. The gnocchi was definitely some of the better gnocchi that I had - it was soft and had a nice bolognese sauce. The only dessert we wanted was tiramisu but they were out, so that was a disappointing end to our nice night out, but overall, I had a great experience at Tutto Carne (if I could give it 4.5 stars I probably would since there were only a few hiccups). It's definitely on the pricey side, and it was hard for us to know what/how much to get as it was our first time. I would certainly come back (as would the other members of my entourage) and get the Tiny Vegetable Garden, a steak, and some sides, maybe pasta if I was extra hungry - skip on the cocktails and salads. If you're looking for a fancy evening out I would recommend checking this spot out!

It's all about quality and this restaurant misses the mark! Of course, you have to pay for good food, but when the price far exceeds what this restaurant delivers it's not worth going back.

NYE led us to Tutto Carne, the new Vintage Italian Steakhouse in Little Italy, Cleveland. While the decor hinted at elegance, the experience fell flat. A last-minute NYE menu swap with minimal changes, mostly inflated prices, set the tone. Our cappuccino martinis, though promising, disappointed with a syrupy, stale taste. The appetizers--bone marrow and steak tartare--were underwhelming. The bone marrow illusion left us with scant portions, overshadowed by excessive toppings. The table steak, ordered medium rare, was decent in temperature but lacked seasoning. The pasta side suffered from an overdose of pepper, under-sauced and over-seasoned. Other items like lobster, truffle pasta, and prosecco were only passable, not justifying the hefty $400 bill for a party of four. While service was commendable, the overall experience left much to be desired. Little Italy boasts numerous fine dining options; Tutto Carne, however, is not one I'd recommend for a memorable night out. Look elsewhere for a more satisfying and reasonably priced culinary adventure.

Had the most wonderful dining experience at Tutto Carne. We'd been intrigued by the name and the location for some time and finally had the opportunity to dine. It was impressive!! From start to finish, no detail spared. The service, the sexy ambiance, the menu, even the names of their specialty cocktails; well done! Looking forward to visiting again soon

Finally a restaurant in Cleveland worth the hype!Everything was absolutely amazing! The drinks were delicious and the food was high quality and prepared perfectly. It's an intimate restaurant which I think adds to the experience. Pricey but worth it, we will definitely be returning as it is our new favorite.

Dark and intimate, once seated Tutto Carne wraps you in its warm embrace. Everything at Tutto is just so, from the perfect pastas to their incredible steaks, to the very well curated wine list - this restaurant knows what it is doing and is not fooling around. Our server, Mary, was extremely knowledgeable about the menu and wine list and made excellent recommendations. Plus, she was unfailingly at our table when needed. We got to meet both the GM, Angela, and Chef Ryan. Both were very friendly and professional, even providing desserts for a birthday.

Fantastic service. Poorly executed food accompanied with exorbitant prices. Very disappointing

I almost never like Italian restaurants in the US as I have been dinner guest at friends from Italy, particularly Calabria, and had the joy of making sausages with their nona one particularly great visit. Given the reviews below, I think you have to be there when one of the prinicpals -the owners, are there. The large table steak was as good as the one I enjoyed in Florence cooked off the hot coals in a giant fireplace. The seafood was served with respect to the natural flavors and delicate textures that get lost with freezing, over-cooking, and pre-cooking (eg shrimp scampi at Olive Garden). The bread -each served fresh and warm -not a stale piece in the basket. The olive oil was good -you can tell by the aromatics that cause a tingly feeling in the back of your throat like you chewed an ibuprophen. The pasta was presented al-dente -a feature sadly lost on many Italian-American restaurants. The vegetables were fresh, the herbs bright and appropriately bitter or sour. The pizza could have been made in a hotter oven, but it's not a pizza place you mouth breather. I liked it, but have to figure out if the boss is in house or not before I book. Very pricey, but was worth it.

Service was fine, the ambiance was fine, cocktails were fine. Dinner was such a major disappointment. At these prices, I don't expect to be chewing fat and grissel. Our party was not interested in spending the evening trying to comprehend the menu, and we all forgot to bring calculators. There is a regular menu and then this baffling list on a chalkboard. Charge by the ounce? We went with the server's recommendation just so we could get back to our conversation. Family style, steak cut up to be shared. Lights are kept low so you can't see how it is trimmed. Lots of fat Veggies and dessert were boring. Not one bite satisfied. Four hundred dollars later I was still hungry. I suppose that if the prices were not so astronomical, I would call this a run-of-the-mill steakhouse. Nothing special here. I wish we had gone to Valerios.