Two Cookies

I don’t know where to start of how good the chocolate chip was. We went for one cookie just try it in case it wasn’t to our liking and I am glad we ordered two instead because it was so delicious, soft, chocolate within every bite and a chocolate explosion that you’ll get to towards the center of it 🥹. It is only two flavors available obviously, chocolate chip cookie and sugar cookie but it is a MUST try! You will not regret because I will be having a monthly bill with this company and become a regular 😂

They only gave me 1/4 of a cookie? Not sure what was going on with that. The cookie itself tasted nice and clean, but it was over in 2 bites. I'd be happy to give this place another try, but the hours they are actually open are so inconsistent. It feels like it is a fun side project versus a real business. They have no physical signage about hours or pricing. Their website says "open daily: 2pm-12am" which is 100% not true. I'm regularly in the area and they are almost always closed. Their website also says the chocolate chip cookies are $4.50, but I was charged $5.25. Lastly, their packaging is very nice... top tier. But it feels incredibly wasteful for smaller transactions. They killed a whole tree just to give me a fourth of a cookie.

A hidden charm the cookie melts in your mouth like none other. The workers were extremely nice one worker gave us a extra cookie because she saw that the cookies were smaller than usual. I love two cookies would heavily recommend

This places just opened up and only sells chocolate chip cookies and sugar cookies. I tried the chocolate chip cookies and they were hands down the best cookies I’ve ever eaten! It was so fresh and delicious tasting! I highly recommend them!

They do one thing (well two) only, and they make it absolutely perfect. Fresh out of the oven, gooey center and crisp edges, just perfect!

The texture was not right because too much sugar and not enough flour in the recipe I guess. The chocolate was good though.

Cookies were delicious and fresh. Staff there was also sweet and super kind, I’ll definitely come back for more.

Amazing cookies! Fresh, soft on the inside and perfectly baked. My favorite spot for a sweet treat!

Yes , they open in weird hours and it's all the way out down there in Fidi . But . It's arguably one of the TOP chocolate chip cookie in NYC !!! Highly recommended!!!! Definitely a Destination!!!!

New contender for best chocolate chip cookie in NYC, in the building next to the fictional Black Rabbit restaurant in the Jason Bateman Netflix show. The two cookies refers to their menu - just a chocolate chip cookie and a sugar cookie. Today it was One Cookie, as the sugar cookies weren't coming out right, but wow was the chocolate chip good. Right out of the oven, finished on the spot with flake salt and super gooey in the middle, with crispy edges.

quite literally the best chocolate chip cookies I've ever had in my life lol... new spot that opened up in seaport that had me intrigued with the name! Stopped by on a weekday night and grabbed a box of two ($7.95) they looked good at first but was blown away when I took a bite. Perfect sweet and salty combo on the outside with a big blob of chocolate in the middle. The perfect cookie for any cookie lover! they also serve sugar cookies so I'll def be back to try those :)

After finding them on IG I knew I wanted to try the cookies from here. They do deliver from Door Dash but I had a little time to stop by to check them out. I ordered a couple of both Chocolate Chip and Sugar Cookies. They were warm so I had to try a little bite of them. I loved the buttery flavor and texture. I like the fact they only serve two flavors, sometimes so many options can be overwhelming lol. The shop is cute inside and the young woman helping me was so friendly and helpful. Definitely will order some again soon!