Dr Z.
Yelp
A thoroughly unimpressive and mostly disappointing bookstore.
The location is not bad and independent bookstores are such an important resource that there should be many more around, so I was more than happy to visit after seeing Unnameable Books on some best-of lists for Brooklyn. I wish it had been worth the visit.
This tiny shop has the potential to be characterful and inviting, but instead it is just confusing and rather uncomfortable. First things first, the books are too expensive for their condition, which is generally quite beat up. The last time I saw books in this condition for sale, they were ex-library. The new books are at cover price, so no big deal there. I am all for giving used books new life, but a paperback for $8-$10 that looks like it's been someone's toilet reading for half a century? No thanks.
The next issue, as other reviewers have mentioned, is the very poor shelf organization. Sure, there are a lot of books, but there is no rhyme or reason for how they are placed on the shelf: not fully alphabetical and not in any real subject order. Even those that are on clearly labelled shelves do not belong to the category stated on the label. If you have OCD for disorganized spaces, you will be pulling your hair out. As for selection, there are plenty of pretentious philosophy-type books and a few overrated literary classics thrown in. A lot have quirky postmodern themes that I suppose fit with the store's ethos on organization (which is to say, disorienting).
It wouldn't be so bad to leisurely browse the tightly packed shelves if you have plenty of time on your hands, but even just a handful of customers will make the task impossible with so little space. It gets exhausting pretty quickly.
Overall, the atmosphere is cramped, the staff nothing special, the clientele - accurately referred to by another reviewer as the "Park Slope stroller crowd" - are loud, and the ambient music is annoying. During my visit, there were a lot of loudmouth patrons obliviously chatting it up (including one giggling incessantly while reading) as well as a barrage of clunking noises, presumably coming from the staff sorting out books. The guy at the desk was eating a sandwich and could easily be the "supercilious owner/manager" referred to in another review. I just want to look for books in a quiet, respectable atmosphere. Is that so much to ask?
Oh, and the sci-fi section is embarrassingly bad.
I reluctantly bumped it up to 2 stars because it's open to 11pm, which is unusual.