Joe F.
Yelp
I want to say upfront: I would rate this a 4.25 to 4.5 if that was possible, but felt it was more of a 4-star than 5 star. Anyways...
I took my wife here for a surprise date night a week ago. Neither of us had been before, but we're both fans of cheese (honestly, who isn't?) It was a Thursday night around 8p and there were only a few other people seated. The place is immaculate; exactly what you would expect from a place that needs to excel when dealing with bacteria cultures and aging.
I ordered a beer (great selection BTW!) and my wife got a glass of wine. We perused the menu and ordered "The Motherboard." The cheese was delicious--no disappointments whatsoever. The accoutrements that were included also featured many fun surprises that I would never think to include on a charcuterie board, but they were excellent additions.
The reason for 4 stars instead of 5 were a few small things that added up:
-after we placed the order for the Motherboard it seemed to take longer than should have been expected. This isn't fast food, I fully realize, but it was long enough that we both kept telling each other, "Shouldn't it be here by now?" Our wait was just as long or longer than a fully prepared meal that includes prep & cooking for a reference.
-the staff working that evening was incredibly nice and very well versed when it came to questions about the cheeses, the facility, and everything under their roof. They just seemed to.... linger. I'm more critical than my wife and was going to let it pass, but when she brought it up I knew it wasn't just me. We DID both agree, that we would rather have someone that's nice and lingers than someone that is rude and short. But when trying to have a date night, you know when that 3rd person isn't part of the date, you know?
-while we were working on (read: devouring) our cheese board, we were starting to run low on crackers and bread. At this point, we couldn't find anyone to ask for more, so we stretched crackers to include much larger portions of cheese. When our waitress visited it seemed the meal was over instead of trying to add these, so we skipped it.
Like I said, very, very small things, but they start to add up. If it was just one, I'd be writing a glowing 5-star review and probably not mention it. Would I go back? ABSOLUTELY and I would also recommend it to people.