Derek K.
Yelp
Rating: 44/100 pts
Venice is an amazingly beautiful city with a not-as-beautiful food situation. All of the popular spots are littered with tourist-trap restaurants betting you're willing to sacrifice quality for scenery. Well, I wasn't, and consequently I walked and walked until I thought I was fully clear of the tourist scene. I wanted me some authentic Venetian cuisine!
From the looks of it, Vino da Gigio had a lot going for it: the exterior was homely, and the menu was filled with Venetian specialities. In fact, they are authentic, and a little on the upscale side. Unfortunately, they're also on the up-price side, but food quality lags behind. You end up spending around €15 for their primi and €24 on a main dish, for the quality of something around half that. Still, food wasn't terrible, and if you can get over the "Venice premium" built into price (and possibly built into the prices of most restaurants here), you do get to choose from an array of Venetian specialties.
They do have some meat items, but I was only interested in seafood. Give me the authentic stuff. I wanted something that Marco Polo, Casanova, or Vivaldi would have called lunch. I've dealt with unfamiliar foods before--show me your stuff, Venice!
...is what I was thinking, but not being brave enough to try some of the more exotic, and thereby authentic choices--cuttlefish (seppie) cooked with ink, eel (anguilla), fried sardines--I went for the grilled sole, which was one of the "pesce del giorno", and I still felt sufficiently Venetian.
The fish was decently fresh, and was served with a small square of polenta. I'd only had polenta a few times before coming here, but this was the least memorable of that I'd had. It was nice and chewy, but thin and insignificant. I've had better in the US, despite polenta originating here in Northern Italy.
I paid around €25 for something not even that filling--though they do give you a huge basket of different types of bread sticks and crackers to snack on.
I was not impressed enough with the food to get dessert, and so my meal ended here. I'd sooner try someplace new than repeat.