Mia M.
Yelp
Worth every penny!!!!!!! Wow. I will be craving this forever. A Lobster Roll to Remember
Every once in a while, you find a spot that captures the pure essence of what Nantucket dining should be simple, fresh, and absolutely unforgettable. Walter's is that spot.
I stopped in for their lobster roll, and easily one of the best I've ever had. The roll was packed with thick, juicy pieces of lobster perfectly fresh, tender, and lightly dressed to let the seafood shine. Every bite felt indulgent but balanced, with just the right touch of butter and seasoning. You can tell the quality here is next-level; it tastes like it came straight off the boat that morning.
The presentation is unfussy in the best way just a clean, well-made roll that lets the flavor speak for itself. It's the kind of meal that instantly transports you into vacation mode, even if you're just stopping in for a quick bite between beach walks.
Walter's itself fits seamlessly into the island's relaxed charm, with friendly walk in service and that quintessential Nantucket vibe. Perfect for a midday lunch or a pre-ferry treat before heading off-island.
Bottom line: If you're in Nantucket and looking for the lobster roll that sets the bar, Walter's is it. No gimmicks, just fresh, local perfection.