Rachel G.
Yelp
First visit and we're already big fans. Heard about this place online and wanted to give it a shot. Came over on a Saturday afternoon around 1pm. There were cars lined up in the side street to get pickup order, which was a good sign! We found out later that the interior seating is closed on the weekend, but you can take your order across the street to Whistle & Keg and enjoy it there with some drinks.
We got the Primanti's sandwich special. French friends, pastrami (and some other meats), coleslaw, and cheese on a long-ass roll. Big sandwich, big taste! The sandwich had well-balanced flavor; it was packed but didn't fall apart after one bite. Another great item we tried was the house spuds. Smashed, fried potatoes with parm, herbs and salt. How could that go wrong? It couldn't. Delish. Lastly, we got a stuffed cookie. First, these things are huge. They weren't on our radar, but the sample cookie sitting at the order window changed our minds and made this a must-try. Yum! Sweet but not cloying, a touch underbaked, stuffed with a brownies? I'm a happy camper. This is definitely a cookie for two... but I'd be happy to eat it solo.
My partner and I are looking forward to coming back to try other sandwiches, and I've got my eye on the churched up fries with toppings. Oh! And in this experience, the service was quick--about 5-6 minutes--but still long enough to know the sandwich and spuds were made-to-order.