Adam R.
Yelp
Update: I finally decided to give Wasabi another try, and am awarding an extra star. This time around I decided to avoid the omakase set menu and just order a variety of dishes a la carte. This seems to be the better approach, and delivered a much more enjoyable experience that my first visit.
Most of the food was quite good to near flawless, although the sauce that accompanied the sirloin steak was far too sweet (though putting some extra wasabi from the sushi rolls onto it balanced it out reasonably well). Real wasabi is available here, though you have to explicitly request it. And they'll accommodate requests for custom maki rolls. Or at least they did when I tried it.
I still cannot say that Wasabi represents good value for money. But it's the only show in town for high-end Japanese cuisine. Stillwater was the closest thing Wasabi had to a worthy competitor, but unfortunately Stillwater shut its doors awhile ago.
-- Original Review, 11/24/2012, 3 stars --
The short version is, the food here is good, but not good enough to justify the price.
I dined here once for a special occasion, my wife and I both ordered the 9-course Omakase set. They scored some big hits with this (ahi sashimi that was as good as any I've ever had, and a sea scallop that was perfectly cooked and flavored) and some big misses (two other scallops in the same dish that were rubbery and gritty, other courses that were under-seasoned, overcooked, and generally not very memorable). The main problem that I have is that for $100+ per person, I expect perfection (or damn close to it), and they fell quite a bit short of that.
Also, the way the Omakase menu is presented you're led to believe that the chef will choose a set of dishes for you specifically. It's even stated that you should note any particular likes and dislikes so that the chef can tailor something specifically to your tastes. I was super-excited by this prospect. The reality of the situation, however, is that everyone who orders the Omakase set is served exactly the same thing. From a logistical standpoint this makes sense (full restaurant, limited number of chefs), but it falls short of the expectation that was created.
And as far as I can tell, none of my likes/dislikes (like: unagi, avocado, cucumber, dislike: uni) were factored in at all. Well okay, I wasn't served anything with uni in it, but then neither was anybody else in the restaurant.
Given the hit-and-miss quality of my experience this place just isn't worth the high price of entry. Had they knocked every single course out of the park like they did with the ahi sashimi then the story might be different. But that's not what happened, at least not when I was there. It's unlikely that I'll return for a second try.