Dave K.
Yelp
I love water song. This is the only decent Chinese food in the city that I have found. I have met the owner, he is a very kind a wonderful person. The ambiance in the restaurant is also great.
All of that said, the food is inconsistent, and it makes me think twice about going.
My wife and I got carry out from water song on Sunday night. We ordered kunming potatoes, kunming noodles, and the new dry ramen. The potatoes were amazing. Possibly the best rendition of that dish we had ever had. I cannot describe how amazing it was. The kunming noodles were ok, but the sauce had spilled in the bag and so it was a bit unbalanced. The dry ramen was ok, but a bit too peppery (this was likely my fault for ordering it extra spicy). All in all, a great meal.
The potatoes were so good in fact, that we decided to order them again the next night. This time they were totally different. Instead of having the red sauce that is spicy and rounded and just so good, they were just doused in pepper, not spicy, just super peppery. I checked the order, we ordered the exact same thing but what we got was totally different.
This is not the first time we have had consistency issues. More than half of the last 5 times we have gotten food there have been some issue with one of the dishes.
This is all to say, even at its worst day, water song is better than any Chinese food I have had in the city. At the same time, you might have an amazing version of a dish one day, and an OK version of it the next...