Water Street Pizzeria

So good !! Service was awesome, the ladies make you feel so welcome, like you're home! All the pizzas were a 10/10 Wings 7/10 (but that's just me, the boys really liked them) Mozzarella sticks 10/10 😋

This is about as basic an option as you can get. It's not "bad" but it's also certainly not great either. Standard cardboard crust and superstore ingredients. Service was good, they had outdoor seating which is a plus, nothing lavish. It was just an "ok" experience for me. I will go to Fratelli's down the road from now on.

My girlfriend and I were visiting my parents from NJ. They said we had to get pizza out in NV. I was skeptical, being a pizza snob from NJ/NYC, but went anyway to give it a shot. We went to Water Street Pizza, and as soon as we walked in, we were met by Jan and Jim (the owners). It was like they had seen us a thousand times, welcomed us, told us to sit anywhere, and gave us hugs. It’s a smaller place with an amazing family atmosphere, but enough with the ambience. We sat down and were greeted by our waitress (Linda). She recommended a few different pies and told us that they were known for their wings. We ordered the naked wings for a starter with sauces on the side. They give a plethora of sauces. The wings were perfect— super crisp but juicy meat along with the sauces. It is worth it just to come for the wings. Now, to the pizza. It’s a beautiful, crispy thin crust with high-end tomatoes that made an amazing sauce and the perfect amount of mozzarella. We got a drizzle of pesto on there as well, which is homemade and to die for. The whole experience was amazing from the owners to the service and the food. It all makes you feel like you’re back at your local pizzeria in NJ/NYC— just comforting and spectacular food.

This time I just came in for a soda and to charge my phone, the times I’ve eaten here. It is next level. The staff is so awesome, so friendly. What a cool atmosphere. This is a place where you can put your phone down for 10 minutes. Have a couple conversations and leave feeling just a little bit better thank you guys so much you guys are awesome.

Small place across the street from the Rainbow casino. We tried the meatball sub made in house from over 16 ingredients, it was very good tasting, texture and flavor were on point. You could tell some TLC went into making them. The fries that come with it and the chicken tenders, were great as well. They have a flavorful coating. Make sure you get Sassy Sauce for the fries, it's way better than ketchup. The customer service was great and friendly staff made for a perfect visit at the end of the evening. We got a carrot cake and cheesecake to go cause they looked so good in the pastry cabinet. The carrot was one of the best I've had.

Ordered the garlic butter cheese pizza for myself and I have no idea what crust she chose for me but I wouldn’t order it again. She didn’t ask. She also didn’t tell us about the BOGO specials that I discovered after we went to sit down at the table. Could have saved some money. It was definitely higher prices than the food quality. Kids were happy. Guess that’s the most important thing. But we won’t be coming back. Iced tea was blah. Thumbs down.

My visits to Water Street Pizza was a delightful experience filled with delicious flavors and cozy ambiance. Tucked away on a quaint corner, this charming mom and pop eatery exudes warmth and hospitality from the moment you walk in. The menu options and quality of the food is awesome. Definitely satisfies the authenticity of real homemade Italian pizzeria. Overall, my experience at Water Street Pizza was truly memorable, and I can't wait to go back for more. If you're in the area and craving a taste of authentic, homemade pizza made with love, this will definitely hit the spot.

I had the meatball sub and it was delicious! The owners were very nice and their chef is from Chicago. I didn't get to try the pizza but I will definitely be back! They also have a nice little patio area which is kid and dog-friendly. Check it out!