Syd C.
Yelp
I would like to begin by mentioning what this store does best- baked goods. Their chocolate chip muffins and double chocolate muffins are the best I've ever had. You can buy them individually or in a case of four. Every good thing that could possibly be said about a muffin applies here. With that said, of course always check the date that's on the label. These muffins are some sort of magic, they stay moist for weeks.
The next thing i want to compliment is their range of products. They have almost everything you could be shopping for. I would compare it to a nicer key foods. The store is very clean and I've been here many times, and never noticed anything out of stock.
But, with that, they are a bit on the pricey side. I normally avoid buying more than their baked goods for that reason. Also, the checkout line is often backed up down the drink aisle, so the layout of that poses an issue if you're looking for beer or soda. Other than that, the line, although it is long, tends to move quickly. Like key foods, their hygiene supplies are also behind the cash registers when you check out, so you don't have much time to browse or decide on an item.
One final note, is the location is pretty convenient. If you go there and don't find what you're looking for, you're 2 blocks or so from the Columbus Whole Foods, key foods, rite aide, and target. So if you want to take a whole shopping day for thanksgiving, it's easy to knock out a lot of places in a single day- given you have the arm strength to carry all your bags.
Depending on where you live you can catch the bus going south on Broadway, and if you're headed north, it's just a block east going to catch the bus on Amsterdam.
TLDR:
The muffins are great. This is reason enough to come here. The selection is also good and the store is clean. Unfortunately it's normally more expensive than key foods, Amazon fresh, etc. The soap, toothpaste, razors, medicine, etc are behind the cash registers so you don't have much time to browse, and there's normally a long line, so it's uncomfortable to choose these things. Luckily it's close to target, rite aid, Whole Foods and key foods on Columbus, so you can get your baked goods here and head that way for all else.