Wild Olive Pizzeria Artisan Sandwiches & Pizza

Please read before you order online. Read the low reviews. The best review is by someone who is new because I’m not biased one way or another. I’m a new customer who will never return. I have ordered multiple times and unfortunately it’s the same each time. It’s August 2025. Wild Olive restaurant does not care if they mess up your order. Wild Olive restaurant will blame you when they mess up your order and tell you we’ll get it right next time…but they won’t. We should boycott restaurants where we get cheated. This is a restaurant where I did not get what I paid for despite calling and speaking to a gentleman naming himself as a manager. Lots of restaurants sell pizza, and grinders, and whatever else is on the menu. Don’t get cheated out of the money that you work hard to earn at a Wild Olive. Wild Olive does not care if they short change you. I ordered a large grinder. I asked for the grinder to be made into a wrap. Instead of giving me the amount of chicken that would go in a large grinder, they gave me a little wrap and some french fries as if I were a child. Boycott, boycott, boycott, boycott, boycott! This is the second time it has happened to me, and there will not be a third disrespect. Boycott, boycott, boycott, boycott, boycott, Wild Olive restaurant. If you don’t know what boycott means look it up and then boycott Wild Olive!! I’ll go first.

Order a Tuna Grinder and the tuna comes seasoned which is unusual, I’ve never had tuna like that anywhere. They mix it with garlic and a leafy season.? It gives it a very bitter aftertaste. It was bad. Like just make a plain tuna and mayo

Visiting from out of town and ordered dinner through Grubhub. It was absolutely delicious!

I just ordered a South Philly Artisan Sandwich which was absolutely delicious minus the fact I only ordered it because it’s supposed to come with garlicky broccoli rabe which I absolutely love broccoli rabe. Instead I got frozen broccoli with thick stems. Very disappointing. It’s false advertisement if they were out of it just say so give me the option to pick a different topping.

They always deliver! Great food every. Single. Time! We order all the time! The grinders and bread are amazing the pizzas are fantastic, the people are nice and very on it! 10 out of 10 recommended. Great food at a great price!

Best grinder I have ever eaten. The artisan bread was amazing and soft. Food was perfectly cooked to order. Toppings were to satisfaction. Employees are friendly and understanding when it came to order taking. Highly will recommend and will definitely be eating at WILD OLIVE AGAIN ☺️

I ordered two large fries , and this was how much I got. I proceeded to order 3 more and each of the boxes had different portions. The first two not even as full as the next three orders. Called them about it and they hung up on me. Why did I order two large fries and IT WASNT EVEN FULL or a large order! But when I order more ya want to fill it up. Can’t even get a refund or a decent convo out of them! This is what I get for 45 dollars

The first time I had the Chicken Alfredo Pizza was at my job , a coworker bought it yesterday .It was so delicious that I had to order it tonight. It had huge hunks of chicken, fresh basil, sliced tomatoes, and so much cheese !! The crust was perfect ! Highly recommend ! It was delivered piping hot and it's soooo good and filling !

Ordered pizza, fries, and mozzarella sticks on a rainy night and delivery was still hot and fresh. The food was delicious and fresh as well. No complaints here! Affordable as well, Wild Olive has very reasonable prices with good quality food. No problems with the service here, no issues with ordering either.

This place is great! The calzones are large and delicious. The marinara sauce is delicious. Employees are pleasant and attention to detail oriented. They deliver to a large area of surrounding towns to their location in Spfld.

We live too far to order directly from Wild Olive for delivery, and as it's my husband's favorite, we use Uber Eats to order from them. The last two times in a row, Wild Olive has messed up the order - I mean entire pizzas just missing - then refused to fix it. They're six miles away but refuse to send a driver to fix what they messed up, and don't care that Uber will not send a driver back to address a mistake by the restaurant. So in the end, they get their money from Uber and give zero sh*ts about whether you actually got what you paid for. Their answer to the problem is "just get a refund from Uber and reorder" - so I have to pay two delivery fees and tips - for something you messed up? Great idea. I now have to wait for Uber Eats to refund my money and am still short on the food I ordered. Terrible place, awful service.

Service is among the worst I've dealt with from pizza shops. Placed an order for delivery at 7:50. Didn't get to me till around 9:30. Anything chicken from them is dry as bones, their grinders lack some components mentioned in the menus. The restaurant itself is disgusting. I do not recommend this place one bit.

Wow, this is the second time I have ordered from Grub Hub and I have to say I've been very disappointed both times. Food arrived cold. The chili is good it's just a very luke warm. I ordered mild chicken wings and obviously received someone else's cold chicken hot strips I called the restaurant and told them I received the wrong order and "no response" literally at the other end of the phone I got "okay."

Very disappointed, ordered the cheeseburger and fried pickles and fried dough EVERYTHING CAME COLD!!! My fries were cold and hard the fried pickles were pretty much all DOUGH, come on now, I spent $40 for this!? Never ordering again

Love the food here. Always excellent and the pizza's are really good. Their subs are great too. I have ordered various things and this place don't disappoint.

Hands down one of the best pizzerias. Never disappointed by their service. Everything is really good and affordable. Absolutely love their mozzarella wedges would highly recommend people to try them!! Also the calzones are awesome!!

My first experience with the Wild Olive was not a great. Food took close to 2 hours to arrive. (We live less then 3 miles away). Chicken wings no flavor boring. Cottage fries,I Don't know what the heck those were. Half deep fried potatoes with flavorless canned chili, cheap cheese floating in a quarter inch of oil in the container. The brushetta. Had potential.Until someone decided Tabasco sauce would be a good ingredient to add. Who does that? You might of wanted to use some of that Tabasco sauce on those boring wings.. On to the calamari. Prebeaded,frozen,rubberbands, pretty sure you can by them at Costco. Ordered 3 salads. Wrong dressing on one .Other than that the salads were ok.. Final comments. If youre not in a rush and you a taste for mediocre food. This is the place for you. My purpose for this review is not to bash them, but hopefully they will read,learn and improve.

We ordered from here through door dash and if I could give a negative star review I would. My fiance and our friends ordered the stuff that if you're a pizza place and you screw it up that you shouldn't be a pizza place. I'm not sure if we got it on a bad night... but oh my lord, this place should not exist as a business. I'm sorry to the staff and management, but you need to taste your food before sending it out. None of us finished anything we ordered. Will not be going to or ordering from again.

I love your wings, but the price has increased significantly, while the quality has gone down while the wings haven't gotten smaller. They doesn't seem fair.

To start this review I will begin with the good. I had the chicken spring rolls, and Mexican torta. Spring rolls were not like the usual ones i have had. They were loaded with cheese and jalapeño, similar to a taquito. I definitely enjoyed the spring rolls but the torta was a different story. The best part of the torta was the avocado, and the outside shell. The shell of the sandwich resembled a panini but with a little more chew to it and good flavor. I chose pulled pork for the torta . pork was extremely dry with a funky flavor. Now the bad. There is no parking here, only in the street and that is limited also. Inside of this place needs to be cleaned at the least, and a fresh coat of paint would be great. I will probably return if in area because i was intrigued by some of their specialty sandwiches and grinders but would not eat inside this place, "very filthy"

Ordered from here for the family on a whim after a long day of swimming. Fantastic! Salads were beautiful and delicious! Appetizers were delicious and not greasy! Pizza was great!! We will definitely order from here again!

Pretty typical pizza spot with subs, appetizers, and salads on their menu along with the pizza. I came here because the pictures of wings from previous reviewers looked delicious. I ordered 18 wings for about $12, which is a steal to me. Their wings come boneless or traditional (with or without breading). I ordered half garlic parmesan and half hot. The wings were a good size, not the puny size I expected for the price. The hot flavor was good but the garlic parm was not that good. It tasted like they sprinkled salt on the wings and called it a day. For the price I wasn't compaining, maybe I just caught them on an off day. The service was not spectacular but they got my order ready to be picked up on time. I'll definitely be back again for their wings and to try other items.

Gave this place another chance. The wings were really good but we will never get a grinder here again. Ordered a steak and cheese and there is barely any steak at all... It's basically a salad on bread.

I ordered takeout tonight and the food was absolutely disgusting it was uncooked and they refused to give me a refund or a new meal. The customer service was horrible and the man I talked to was very rude and told me that my food was fine even though he didn't see it. I'm very upset at the service I received. I only ordered here because I thought the food was good but I will NEVER be ordering from them again. 10/10 would not recommend EDIT: the rude man I spoke to earlier called back to thank me for my yelp review and then proceded to tell me that Grubhub wasn't answering their calls. When i contacted Grubhub they informed me that the restaurant refused to give me a refund because they felt there was nothing wrong with serving a person raw cold shrimp.

I came here with friends after a long day at Six Flags. We were exhausted and starving. We got the deal with a large cheese pizza, 10 piece wings, and 2L soda. Hit the spot. The pizza was blazing hot and super cheesy. The place was decently clean and it was the end ot he night. We did have to ask for napkins though.

Everything was nice , except for them big ass wings they give you with the pizza and soda meal. Horrible and imma give a half star for the dinosaur wings. The pizza was fabulous, I will give that 10 stars any day.

because they had a big group of people come in and i went to grab my food they said 20-30mins and then we came back 40mins after still later than the time they said i walk in they say whats your order and they also said we dont have it after telling me it would be ready and it wasnt.

Supervisor never called. I didn't bother to pursue obviously not a responsible business. Don't waste $ here!!!

Ordered and picked up a large half cheese half pepperoni pizza to go. It smelled delicious in the car. It is some of the best pizza in the area! Right up the with Pizza Works!Going to be hard to choose between the two... Excellent crunchy crust and a tasty sauce and cheese combo: all of the typical pizza elements were on point here as well. Will be back to see what else they offer that may be as good.

WORST CUSTOMER SERVICE EXPERIENCE EVER. They messed up my order so I politely called to see how we could resolve the issue and the person who made my pizza answered the pgone and proceeded to tell me how the order was fine because HE made it. He then proceeded to ask what i wanted, to which i replied I wanted to resolve the minor issue and he began to get angrier and hung up. Grrrrrreat

Been ordering from here late night since my friend moved to the area. Usually order online and the food is typically pretty good and ready on time. Buffalo chicken pizza is great! A couple of times they've forgotten silverware/napkins and the service isn't the friendliest - but the food is good, basic and pretty consistent.

After a very long day on the road, we decided to try out Wild Olive. I like the GrubHub setup on their website. It was easy to use & very convenient. After you order, you get a designated time to pick up. Our food was hot & ready at that time. Nice. We settled on a couple of customized pizzas, a rustic meatball grinder, a grilled buffalo chicken salad, waffle fries, sweet potato fries & fried Oreos. Pizzas were very nicely done with quality ingredients. The kids destroyed them along with the loaded waffle fries & fried Oreos. The grinder was very good...though I like my meatball grinders a little heavier on the sauce & cheese. The meatballs & shaved sausage were very tasty though. The salad was excellent with what looked like a whole chicken breast...very nicely prepared with excellent house vinaigrette. Sweet potato fries were nice & crunchy with a superb spicy chipotle ketchup! Staff was friendly & hard at work when I picked up...churning out orders. There are a couple of tables inside but this is definitely a take-out joint. We'll be back for sure.

Forgot half the order, overcharged. Called to inquire on all the above and the guy couldn't be ruder, seem to not really care. Oh yeah, make sure you order online and don't call because then it's extra if you call it in because that makes sense? Shady, greedy business.

I know times are tough, and I try not to be so tough, but I'm really disappointed. We ordered tonight and the calzone that we received was a meat calzone, when we ordered a "wild olive calzone." I also ordered an antipasto salad, that didn't have ANYTHING in it that it was supposed to have. It actually barely had anything on it besides greens. I tipped well in desperate times, and was really disappointed.

The only thing that was good was the pulled pork spring rolls. The mozzarella wedges had way to much breading and the Steak spring rolls was not even steak.

Might be my new favorite place in Springfield. I've ordered 2 large orders from them and they have been completely helpful and got our orders right both times. I have tried the south philly & black and blue artisan sandwiches and out of the two I enjoyed both. The thing that stood out to me was the meat in both. They were both very tender and delicious. Our players (17-21 year olds) ranted and raved about their chicken wings, so I guess that's a good sign. We will be ordering from them again and again.

They have delicious panini's, generous portions, and fresh ingredients at a good price. They have a huge variety of options on their menu and I've only tried a few but I am excited to try so many more sandwiches and grinders. I love the Wild Olive panini with chicken. Really good.

Delivery was over 40 mins late, called to ask about the status of my order and talked to a very rude guy on the phone. Granted it is super bowl Sunday and I figured delivery would be a little late but the rudeness I received for just inquiring about my order is not OK. Worst part was the food was cold and not good at all.

Just moved to the area 4 months ago and have tried a lot of pizza around me but this one, for me, was my favorite so far. I had the bruschetta, French fry pizza, and cheese bread. My husband had the meat lovers and wings. After the first bite we both just gave each other "the look" confirming our new obsession! We had the pizza on Friday and I just woke up two hours ago on Sunday and I still can't stop thinking about this place. Yum yum in my tum tum. 10/10 would recommend!

Place used to be amazing. Now it's pretty awful. Got the Reuben burger. It looked like they used a frozen pre cooked burger patty and heated it up on the grill. They even managed to burn it. The one slice of pastrami they used was pretty decent. It's pretty sad when a restaurant doesn't care for the quality of their food. Never going to order from there again.

We used to love this place but the last few times we've ordered from them have been disappointing. We're from the NY / NJ area and their pizza used to be really good thin crust pizza. But the crust hasn't been thin and crispy for months, so we'd switched to other options. But tonight I ordered a caesar salad with chicken but their website didn't let me choose caesar dressing. I chose creamy italian and got "golden italian". Mix ups happen but this dressing was WAY too sweet, and didn't compliment the chicken at all. Mainly because the chicken was over seasoned, visibly over seasoned. The chicken almost looked like it was covered in pesto.

This place is great.. I would never go to nucci's when It was there but I love a great sandwich and this place has a great selection and prices. I have been here 4 times since it has opened a few weeks ago. 1st trip I ordered the mozzarella sticks and the Cuban sandwich. The mozzarella was fresh and was in triangles and was fresh and delicious. You can tell they were homemade which around here is really rare. The pork was really amazing as well. 2nd Trip for lunch I stopped in and ordered the Southwest Philly steak sandwich it had shallots and this spicy mayo that was really good. I think this was my favorite or the bunch. the Rib eye was tender and sliced very thin. 3rd trip I wanted to have the Philly steak again but I forced myself to try something different so I ordered the chicken bacon ranch wrap to try the fried chicken. I was happy to say that the chicken is also not frozen. thank goodness for people who actually still cook. 4th trip was last night with my wife I had the Napa Valley turkey sandwich it was delicious. I couldn't finish it my wife ordered a combo pizza and she loved it. I ate a few pieces and thought the sauce was really good and had a good crust. You really should try this place. The selection is going to be like nothing else in the area. Not your normal pizza shop. Great breads for the sandwiches.

Wing Wednesday rules!!!! 50 cent a wing.....Got all of this for $7.95, see you next Wednesday!!

Horrible service this afternoon!!! I have been ordering from here for so long spent large amounts of money with them and the disrespect torwards me over soda that they have advertised on their menu. Waited over an hour after they said 45 mins. Nice to know this is how they treat loyal customers. The man accused me of swearing in front of my kids! Very disappointed!

Horrible customer service. The lady was cursing at me through the phone cause I was explaining that there's bug in my grinder and my pizza is cold. Mind you they was 30 minutes late!

When we want to order "out of the ordinary", Wild Olive's is the place to go! Their sandwiches are the best!

I wanted to try a new local pizza place. This one is right around the corner. I decided to get the Jerk Chicken wings, Garlic Bread and A Pepperoni pizza. Order came in a very timely fashion. Pizza was plain ole cheese, no big deal. I call and they send out a new one. New one comes 45 minutes later(1hr and 30 minutes after placing my initial order). PIzza is hot and pepperoni. However, The pizza is bland as hell, the bottom was over cooked and slightly burnt. The sauce had no flavor and the cheese was no better. The only good thing I can say is the jerk chicken is really good. I will not be ordering from their again. If you can, I suggest you get Village Pizza on Audobon St. I will not make this same mistake twice. A very expensive and disgusting mistake over all.

I had the gf caprese panini, cheese tortellini soup and cobb salad. Everything was excellent and arrived hot to my house.

I placed order it 2hours late. Special excepts I asked on salad was not done . Asked for extra corn , beans and cheese No onions salad had a lot of red onions. They must read additional comments . Asked for barbecue sauce on chicken after speaking with server wanted extra sauce . Chicken had small amount of sauce. I was unhappy..

I ordered a slice of cheese pizza and when i went to pick it up it wasn't ready. The owner was counting money on the serving counter and when my husband asked how long does it take to heat up a slice of pizza the owner said so what. We left and when i looked in the window you can see an employee sitting on the counter where they prepare the food and another employee counting money on it as well... I will never go back there..

It makes me happy to report that Springfield is lucky to have another name to add to its embarrassingly short list of quality pizzerias. That name is Wild Olive Pizza. And I'm actually a little embarrassed it's taken me as long as it has to find out about the establishment, which has made its home, not too far from my own home, in the former Nucci's location on Sumner Avenue just above the "X". Enticed by their menu which uses the word "artisan" and advertises several eclectic items -- appetizer, sandwich, and pizza recipes boasting high quality, some might say "gourmet", ingredients the likes of which aren't necessarily offered at other pizza restaurants in the city -- I ordered a pie and a couple of appetizers. Everything, including the buffalo chicken spring rolls, and enormous triangular chunks of fried mozzarella, tasted fantastic and bore the glorious flavor of being hand made! Artisan is right! Across the board, this place just doesn't serve the frozen junk you're likely to find at most other streetside pizza joints! My only, minor complaint is that the serving size of some of the apps may need adjusting. I got three gigantic chunks of fried mozzarella, more than enough to share. But three of the crispy, delicious spring rolls was barely enough to satisfy me, much less enough to share. Work on it guys! The pizza itself was rock-solid, if not remarkable. The crust is soft and chewy throughout, and cooked to a slight crispness on the edges so it all holds together and is easy to pick up. It's also easy to chew, maintaining the pillowy quality of dough while still giving you a little bite towards the end. This isn't the hard, seemingly endless slog of gummy, tasteless, mush, or the jaw-cracking, tooth-breaking, sandpapery crunch that a lot of other local spots are so fond of giving you. And thankfully there's no sign of the cornmeal plague that infects so many other Springfield pizzerias. The stuff that goes on the crust is just as important though, and it's apparent the folks behind Wild Olive are going for quality. The sauce, cheese, vegetables and meats all tasted fresh. Even on the second day, slices from my party-size pie still tasted awesome, and remained chewable, after a quick nuking! Maybe it's just me, but I think it's great to see someone in Springfield doing pizza and its accouterments THEIR WAY rather than the cookie cutter method everyone else -- including the big boys who are often touted as the best in the city -- seems to be doing it. Their menu is a breath of fresh air, and they seem to be living up to their own hype when it comes to handmade quality as well. It was clear that actual care went into the preparation of the food I ordered from Wild Olive. And THAT is something you can taste.

This is a great place for delivery. The wings are the best. My favorite grinders are the Fat Kev...the pastrami is amazing. Their paninis are also good...my fav is the Rueben.

Wild Olive Pizza review: Wild Olive Pizza is on Summer Ave where Nuccis used to be. First, let me say that I am sort of a pizza nut. I am very particular about pizza. Not only have i eaten probably hundreds of pizzas, I also have worked in a pizza restaurant. It should be noted that this restaurant is definitely more of a takeout joint rather than an eat in restaurant. Here is my initial impression based on my one visit. The Good: Wild Olive has a really good pizza menu. They offer both traditional pizza toppings, as well as some more unusual combinations that you don't normally see in pizza joints around Springfield such as "shaved sausage " and "San marzano tomato sauce". Many of their pizzas offer premium ingredients and interesting flavor combinations. The prices are not astronomical as some of the pizza places in the area such as Frankie and Johnny's. On the flipside, the large pizza I ordered was really a medium and I think it should have been priced about two dollars cheaper. The Bad: When judging a pizza, I am looking for several different things. Although there are many different types and styles of pizza making, every pizza should have three fundamental ingredients. A great crust. A flavorful sauce. And fresh toppings. My first pizza from this restaurant was the California pizza. First, there crust recipe needs some work. The end of the crust, the part that you hold, was too thick. The dough needed a pinch more salt, and lacked flavor. Overall, the pizza, although hot and fresh, was tough and difficult to chew. Next there was the sauce. The sauce had a good tomato flavor, but there was not enough sauce on the pizza which left it rather dry. The toppings on the pizza, consisted of tomatoes, basil, mozzarella balls, and grilled chicken. The description of the pizza was a little misleading. The roasted tomatoes that were described on the menu actually did not seem to be roasted at all. There were no actual basil leaves on this pizza but rather what seemed to be a basil pesto. I love basil pesto. However, it was so unevenly and sparingly applied to the pizza that only about half the pizza slices even had any pesto on them. The grilled chicken seem to be real chicken and not the processed crap that some pizza places try to pass off. Overall I would give the pizza two out of five stars, however, I would be willing to try this place one more time based on the fact that they have unique offerings. Sometimes a new place needs some time to work out the kinks

We ordered a pizza with mushrooms on the side and they arrived uncooked...never in my life have I seen a delivery like this before

I have found myself coming back here, time and again. The pizza (pulled pork, chicken bacon ranch) are some of my absolute favorite. Everything tastes homemade and despite that, everything is a low price. The appetizers are also delicious as well! Definitely order, but delivery can take quite a while.

Friendly & flexible staff, delicious food, a few vegetarian options (more would be better!). Would love to see whole grain pasta & gnocchi dishes too.

I do enjoy their food it is good, but good grief I don't know what they got going on back there behind the scenes. It seems to take FOREVER to get anything out of the kitchen. I never go there unless I have a lot of time. The delivery driver leaves a lot to be desired too.