Yardley Ice House

I’m confused about this place. Maybe the girl was new but she said there has never ever been ice cream ever sold. But I look at the pictures and the 23 other reviews about the soft serve and I see ice cream. I didn’t even know that the flavors on the wall were water ice and that’s not anyone else fault. I didn’t know where I was. I got the peanut butter cup ice and it was alright. I think I rather have polish water ice. But that’s just my opinion. My friend got some blizzard type jawn and I thought that was a lot better so maybe I just got the wrong thing. I did ask if there were any ice cream places around and she said she didn’t know. That’s fine too. There is one single bench outside. I’ve never been there so I don’t know if they put more places to sit when it’s the summer. That’s really all. I don’t need to go back. They do have pup cups for your pup.

This is a little ice cream joint tucked behind Mil-Lee’s Diner. Although it’s not on the main street, people know it’s there because there was a line when we arrived. The people behind the counter kept the line moving. We had orange cream water ice with vanilla soft serve on top. It was creamy and delicious. Worth the wait in line!! They only take cash.

CASH ONLY. The staff is very sweet & patient despite the very busy crowd pouring into the small shop. The hardest part is deciding which flavor of water ice to pick; there are too many unique and delicious flavors but the sweet girls let you sample the flavors first. I do not like soft serve but I was incredibly impressed with the quality snd richness of the soft serve here. They offer a size small which is very cute and convenient so I was able to get two different flavors.

Highly recommend for the water ice, but not sure what's going on with the soft serve cones. Just went there and paid $15 for the two tiniest cones ever. We had toppings, but ouch! And the chocolate dip was somehow very thin. When asked about why so small was told this is how it's always been, and they actually weigh to be sure. I was watching and no weighing happened. I've been going here over 25 years and the cones were always generous. I don't mind paying for a good product, just make it worthwhile and don't make it seem like it's me! Go somewhere else if you want a cone of soft serve.

My cup of “water ice” was all water and food coloring. It’s thick like syrup. No ice at all, it’s beyond me why the staff would serve that and charge someone for it. $16 for a small water ice that had to be thrown away and 2 cones, one of which fell off the cone because it was so lopsided. The ice cream is not custard, it was whipped with so much air, there is not creamy thickness you normally get with custard. We’ve been coming for years , but this time was too much and we won’t be back.

This is the only place that I’ll go the extra mile to get my water ice fix. I have been coming with friends and family for over 20 years, it is The Best handcrafted Water Ice; always innovative and fun. Without a doubt, you will find something new that will be your next favorite.

This is an amazing place. The lines are long for a reason. The ice is lovely after a hot day. It’s also in a very nice location. WORTH IT!!!!

The soft serve is good, but there really isn't a lot of flavor selections. The milkshake game is on point though 👍