Stephanie El-Hajj
Google
10/10 for the pastrami. I didn't even think I liked pastrami but after that sando I'm converted. Just enough mustard, flavorful and soft rye bread. Perfection. Apologies to any new yorkers rolling over, but it worked for me.
The tiny little shop is full of nostalgic snacks like Voodoo chips, Fruit Stripe (pretty sure that's what it was), Yoo-Hoo. It creates a fun vibe. 5/5 for snacks.
I got the black & white cookie, which comes from Ivy & the Poet (it's on my try list!), It was good. 4/5 just because it didn't wow me.
I got a fresh and a day-old bagel, to compare. The day old plain I chucked in the toaster with a bit of water to revive it - it tasted like bland. It would me a lot happier in sandwich form, which isn't how I bagel. I'm happy with plain cream cheese. The everything fresh bagel was much more flavorful, the chew was fine, but I prefer my bagels to have a tighter skin and bubbles, so overall 4/5 for the bagels.
Would I go back for the bagel and cookie, no, probably not. Would I push someone out of the way to get the last bit of pastrami? Without hesitation.
The folks behind the counter were goofy and fun and they sling good food. I'll def be back to try the Ruben.