James G.
Yelp
You won't find a better selection of items on the menu here and a great rotation of beers. The wine selection covers all of the bases, even if the cost is about 50% more than you'll find anywhere else on the island.
The staff are attentive if a bit confused and naive. With a generosity of spirit, they are likely to be confused about what's on tap. They don't know one wine from another but friendly. Nice enough.
The beers here are also 25% more than at the local brewery who makes them, so if you are in a budget you might just head over to 1718.
Even the figgy items are more expensive than at the Variety Store. They even over-charge for a sticker that should be given away or cheap to advertise their store.
Finally, just be warned that they do not like cats here, and while there are no signs prohibiting pets, don't be fooled and just don't bring you kittens; that's when the staff show their teeth through Cheshire grins and give you the cold should and the bum's rush.
In conclusion, if you're looking for a one stop party shop, and price is not a concern, and you have an unlimited budget, then Zillie's is your place! Stop by -- but bring your wallet!
And curiously the owner has made up a story that I am totally unfamiliar with. He must have me confused with someone. Anyway he seems awfully engaged -- obsessed -- with social media. Maybe if he paid more attention to his business rather than bullying his customers on Yelp. I do feel for him -- it is very hard to deal with finding good staff who are knowledgeable about cuisine. And inflation is through the roof, but with $30,000 in government PPP pandemic cash, this business should be faring well.