"And damned if the hamburger didn’t make a nearly identical claim, calling itself the “highest rated burger in NYC”... Called the Suprema burger ($19), it entailed black garlic sauce, aged cheddar, roasted tomatoes, and Iberico Bellota jam... it really delivered on the flavor front... But the highest-rated burger? The observation turned out to be attributed to the Gotham Burger Social Club... Ultimately, I’d eaten two burgers that bragged they were the city’s best but clearly weren’t." - Robert Sietsema
