"Smack dab in downtown Nantucket’s historic district, this rowdy piano bar has regular live entertainment and excellent piña coladas. Open for brunch and dinner, you’ll find a well-executed seafood-focused menu with plates that you’ll want to share, like steamed mussels with root vegetable chips, crab cake swimming in beurre blanc, and grilled octopus with zucchini fritters. This is where everyone on the island goes to drink, snack a little, and sing along in a club car from the original Nantucket railroad." - tanya edwards