1
"At the southern tip of City Island Avenue Tony's Pier presents itself as a mid-century-era, counter-service seafood restaurant with the same charming, station-based ordering system (raw, steamed, broiled, fried, frozen tiki drinks) and plentiful outdoor picnic tables as its neighbor Johnny's, creating a retro, no-frills seaside atmosphere that makes it an essential stop on the island." - Hannah Goldfield