Steph C.
Yelp
We wanted to grab a drink after watching a play, and one of my friends suggested Jimmy Buffett's Margaritaville. I didn't have the highest hopes for a chain joint in Times Square, but she'd been before and said it was easy and nice.
She was more than right. We went up to the 5 o'Clock Somewhere Bar, and it was somehow the most chill rooftop bar I have ever visited, a genuine Times Square oasis, floating above the busy streets. There were open tables inside, and we sat down and ordered before moving outside, where it was worth a little cold to enjoy the city view. We were able to snag a table there, too. I guess 10:00 on a Wednesday is an off-peak hour, but the place really was unbelievably civilized. Service was great, too. We had a waiter who took excellent care of us.
The drinks were solid, not the main draw, but at least as good as they had to be. I got the signature Midtown Margarita, made with Maestro Dobel reposado tequila, Grand Marnier, Ancho Reyes, agave, lime juice, and egg white. I also tried my friend's W. 40th St & Agave, with Casamigo's blanco tequila, Grand Marnier, earl grey agave, and lime juice. These sounded less sweet than most of the menu and were still definitely on the sweeter side.
I was happy with my margarita and would've stayed for more if it weren't already late on a weeknight. I had a lovely time at Jimmy Buffett's Margaritaville's 5 o'Clock Somewhere Bar. I'd highly recommend it if you're looking for a place to drink in Times Square.