Vickie W.
Yelp
I started seeing articles about ACQ Bread in early December, and while I was intrigued by the baking process and the community-focused culture behind the bakery, I figured I was never going to schlep to Carroll Gardens to pick up a loaf of bread. But one night in December, I saw ACQ loaves being sold at Dimes Market in Chinatown, accompanied by a sheet of paper which described the genesis of the loaf and the baker's inspiration. True to form, I was transfixed by evocative copy, and walked out with a fluffy loaf of ACQ's milk bread. As a child who's only gateway to sweets was the Asian supermarket, I am very familiar with various types of Asian milk breads, and was truthfully somewhat skeptical that this loaf was going to truly blow me away (but again: the copy was SO GOOD, I highly recommend you go to ACQ's website and read it, if you've made it this far in this review). But holy hell. This loaf is the king of milk breads. Really fluffy and buoyant texture, but simultaneously dense and rich. Flavor is a little sweet, a little tangy. It's amazing.
This weekend, I knew I was going to be in the area for dinner, and took the opportunity to pre-order a half loaf of the rye bread for pickup Saturday evening. It's a very easy, socially-distanced pickup: you ring a little bell outside the bakery, give Tyler (who runs ACQ) your name, and he grabs your freshly baked bread. It smelled so amazing just standing in the doorway, even through my mask. Apparently this was because Tyler had just put the chocolate milk bread in the oven, so that may need to be my next buy. (I truly wish I could attach a smell-o-vision file to this review, it was so heavenly.)
I'm also happy to report that the rye bread is similarly jaw-dropping. Sliced into it this morning, and paired the untoasted slice with some whipped cream cheese and berries: toasted seeds make for a crunchy, fragrant crust, and the flavor of the bread is rich and nuanced, very satisfying and hearty. It's a dense, close-textured bread, but not dry and doesn't scream "health bread" the way some ryes do. I'm already excited to eat this for breakfast tomorrow.