David O.
Yelp
I read a lot about Alba. Actually, I first read about Harbinger which led me back to Alba. Sometimes, you take a restaurant and the setting and its people produce a long lineage of incredible chefs. Think French Laundry, Charlie Palmer, etc... Sometimes, the Chef is just so bloody brilliant that when he moves on, the place loses its luster. Alba...
I can't quite tell you which way Alba goes. I'm a picky foodie mofo who lives in the Bay Area and is willing to spend upwards of 30% of his income on good food and good wine. I thought the food at Alba was very solid. If I were working for the Michelin guide, however, there's no way in hell I'd ever give them a star. I'm sorry, Alba. You've sure as hell got potential but you need to polish that rough jewel...
Service? Service was friendly and amiable when it was there. My server showed up every 25 minutes or so. Apparently, he apologized, I was behind a large party. Hmmm, I'm thinking, I guess they probably will bring a better tip, so fuck the guy dining solo. Sucks to be me... You know what, though, I've been at restaurants that get swamped. I get that. Think smart, though. If I order a drink and you know it's going to be a while until I get my food, bring me my goddamn drink, ok? It's no substitute for food but it sure makes it easier to pass the time.
I started out with the beignets. I texted my wife a picture of the menu and she thought that would be a good bet. I certainly was intrigued... Porcini & Shitake Beignets. Sounds sexy, right? Yeah, it was tasty and as you can see from the picture I've posted, the presentation was very nice. Still, they're not beignets as much as mushroom croquettes. I expect fluff and airiness with my beignets. These morsels had hardly any crunch.
I followed it up with a marinated hanger steak which showed up some 45 minutes later. It was good. The steak was medium rare, as they suggested it be served and there's really no complaint there. The steak was prepared correctly and the potato pave drew some admiration from yours truly. But $31? No offense, Des Moines, but that's what I pay for such a dish in the Bay Area, and I live in a house that's worth over a million bucks! (Well, I don't think it's worth more than $750k and that's why I'm renting said house, but that's a whole different story...) $31? Y'all aren't outraged with that price?
When I finally got my entree, my waiter brought along some bread. Duuude... Why didn't you bring the bread, like, some 20 minutes ago? You do realize I was analyzing the wood in your beautifully polished table, aren't you? I could have been eating your housemade bread instead? Sheessshhhhh...
I got a drink to start the evening. A cocktail, to be exact, called Mother of Necessity. That was a beautiful and absolutely stellar cocktail! Alba, you need to keep your bartender and give him or her a big fat raise. On the other hand, you may want to consider hiring a proper sommelier or, at least, hire one on a consultancy basis. You server boutique small wineries, I get that. If you're going to serve Shafer, though, you really ought to be serving their red wines like Relentless or One Point Five. Their Chardonnay's ok but... And I like the Los Olivos wine region. It's got some solid wine. But Stolpman, really? Beckmen, Hitching Post, Jonata, Zaca Mesa, I get... Sorry Stolpman but, ... really?
I know I'm being harsh. I gave them 4 stars and I think they have potential but they need to polish up their game a little bit. And guys, if you want some help with beignets or with improving your game, feel free to DM me. My wife used to be Executive Pastry Chef at l'Auberge du Soleil and the Culinary Institute of America, both in Napa. She's available for consulting engagements.