Paul R.
Yelp
Our second time at Alderwood. The first was during the pandemic period, so we wanted to come back and see what might be different since we were in town for the weekend.
One thing I noticed is that the portion sizes were HUGE. I we likely should have only ordered one starter and one main instead of one each and then sides for our main.
We started with a bottle of Paul Bara grand cru rosé champagne. It had a little tartness to it but lovely bottle, highly recommend.
For starters, I got the parmesan popover and my hubby got the avocado. The popovers were gigantic, and I got three, and it was a deconstructed sort of finish with items to assemble - overall, it was tasty but not amazing, would likely not get this one again. My hubby's avocado was very tasty and he gave it an 8 out of 10, and a little on the smaller side, with it being a half an avocado (which was perfect as a starter for portion size).
For mains, I did the 8oz fillet accompanied by the Hen of the Woods side. The fillet was perfectly done. Highly recommend. The Hen of the Woods had me concerned but it was one of the dishes that made them a known name, so I rolled with it. It did NOT disappoint. Wow, who knew that mushrooms and maple could go together? Highly recommend this side dish. My hubby, as a Mainer, ordered the diver scallops from Maine. He gave it a 7 out of 10 and said he would have likely picked something else. It was ok, but nothing exciting that made it memorable. His side was the broccoli and peppers. It was a substantial portion but didn't have a pop with flavor in any way.
We passed on dessert because everything was so big and filling lol! My colleague who is in Santa Cruz a lot stated that she only eats a burger about 3x per year, and Alderwood's is one that she's make one of her three (she likes it that much). I saw it go by and it did look amazing.
Service was a little wonky at seating. And initial communication - as the server made a lot of odd assumptions and interrupted us several times. We just smiled and rolled with it, but candidly was a bit strange. Things improved after that and the rest of the evening was great.
If you're in Santa Cruz, you'd be an idiot not to make a stop here.