Brandon B.
Yelp
Average pizza with great crust, and cannoli you can skip.
Having seen Andy on Reddit and with the recent award, my wife and I went in with sky-high hopes. That was our own mistake, as reality didn't deliver.
We got a pick-8, Brussels sprouts, and cannoli. The first piece I ate was the cheese (it won the award.) Good, but nothing special. Then the pepperoni, better with a good crust. Then the sausage and pepper, which was nothing special. Even with an oven re-heat, it was floppy and a mess. Then the white, which my wife threw away.
Brussels were excellent. Then we get to the reason for the three star review. The absolute worst cannoli I've ever had. The crust melted in your mouth instead of providing a solid crunch, and the filling was gritty and chunky. I've eaten close to a hundred cannoli, and this was a very bad first--it's not supposed to taste like the cream spoiled. I can't even really articulate how off the taste was.
I've seen Andy on Reddit, and I really wanted to like and give this five stars. However, in the end, my wife said it the best: "We should have just ordered All Purpose."
I know that sucks to read and to write, but I have to agree with her. At least that is a solid four star, if not five star, experience every time.