Anthony's Italian Deli

After a long day on the road, we were looking forward to our first meal in Baton Rouge, and Anthony’s seemed like a great pick. We love mom-and-pop places and enjoy Italian food, so the glowing reviews and long history had us excited. The staff was warm and friendly, and we appreciated the welcoming atmosphere. That said, we wish someone had advised us more strongly on portion sizes—while the comment “Y’all are going to have a lot of food” was made, we didn’t realize just how much. One Muffoletta would have been plenty for the two of us. We ordered the New Orleans Style Muffoletta, the Godfather, and a stuffed artichoke. Unfortunately, the food didn’t live up to our expectations. The sandwiches were average, and the stuffed artichoke was especially disappointing—it was so tough and fibrous that I couldn’t eat it, despite really wanting to enjoy it. I have fond memories of my mother preparing tender artichokes when I was young, and this one didn’t compare. One Muffoletta could easily serve a family of four with average appetites, perhaps with a side or two to share for those with heartier appetites. I do wish the size of the sandwiches had been explained to us, especially since we mentioned to the person taking our order that it was our first time visiting. We decided to give dessert a try, thinking we couldn’t go wrong with a classic cannoli—but unfortunately, we were disappointed once again. It lacked flavor and just didn’t hit the mark. We’re not sure if we just ordered the wrong items, given how many people seem to love this place. If we’re ever back in the area, we might give it another try and go for something from the pasta menu instead.

Just wow!! This place is phenomenal! The service was incredible and the food was outstanding! The atmosphere gives a feeling of sitting at a bistro in Italy. I had the Italian Lovers and pasta salad. If I am ever back in town this will be my go to every time.

@tableformaddie on instagram!! My oh my!!! My favorite food is Italian so i came in judging everything really hard!!! This place was absolutely amazing!!!! I had the shrimp spaghetti, which was great but i could not stop eating my boyfriends Deli sandwich!! It was absolutely out of this world!! Now that i know the food here is good i cannot wait to come back!! & dont get me started on hoe friendly the staff was!!!! I love it here!!!! Thank yall so much!!

Ordered 1/2 muffuletta with a house salad. Counter service was very friendly and attentive. The house salad was delicious with the balsamic dressing. The muffuletta is very good, but if you’re a fan they do use a little bit different bread than you may have had at other places. Here the bread is thinner and crisp. I really enjoyed my meal and I’m eager to return and try more menu items.

Great little spot for lunch…the meatballs and homemade sausage reminds me of my grandmas Sunday dinners. The sausage was fantastic w that little bit of fennel that was just right …Meatballs on par with the sausage . The only real letdown was the dessert . The cannoli was watery and loose with no signs of mascarpone to be found anywhere . The split cherry on it was also disappointing to see. The cannoli shell itself being from Ferraras was crispy crunchy and held up to the watery filling as well as it could. Overall go for the Italians meats and meals they are well worth it.

Amazing food and Italian nostalgia supreme! We found this gem while looking for the best muffuletta in Baton Rouge and our lunch far exceeded any expectations we could have possibly had! The meatballs were amazing and we were licking the containers of the creme brulee, almond cake, and tiramisu! Quite possibly one of the best meals we had in our five days in Louisiana and the service left an even better impression. Reminded me of my Italian grandpa's heart that everyone you feed is a friend and every friend is family. Something that seems to run true from the pictures on every inch of the wall.

We stopped here on our drive up to New Orleans. I ended up liking this place’s muffuletta more than Central Grocery (which is where the muffuletta originated from)! It was so good - the bread was toasted perfectly and the cheese and meat went very well together. Super cozy mom and pop shop with plenty of parking space. Highly recommend stopping here for a bite!

Wonderful meal, great service. 10 out of 10! Don’t drive by this place.

I've been a patron of Anthony's Italian Deli for a long while. When I first discovered it, they were located in a tiny space out in the back of a commercial building on Florida Blvd. East. Now they are in a much better, but still cozy, space on Government Street. This facility has indoor dining space, patio dining space, and plenty of parking, including a back overflow lot. Anthony's has been in business so long due to authentic Italian cuisine, including a great variety of take out deli items. If you need some real Italian grocery items for your home, there's a good chance you can get them at Anthony's. However, if you would rather let them prepare your meal for you, that's an excellent option as well. I think they have a first rate muffuletta, and it's important to have the right bread and meats for those. This is something they have covered! Their Po-Boys are also my favorites. These are pressed so they are crispy and flattened. I typically like to get these with a small salad, which is indeed an excellent choice. If you have room, there's always some great dessert choices. Another consideration is picking up something to take home for later, I think a tub of high quality imported olives are a good selection. Don't forget their cheeses as well, these can lift your home cooking to a higher level. Next time you are in the Government Street Arts and Entertainment District, drop into Anthony's for a bite, dessert, or take home items. You'll definitely thank yourself later!

Nice folks. Clean restaurant and great service. The muffuletta was okay. Not sure it's worthy of high praise. I'm sure it's rated high by locals primarily

I'm in town for work and I came through here to get a to go plate for lunch. The restaurant itself has a lovely dining area filled with memorabilia showing the history of this beloved establishment. They have indoor and outdoor seating at comfortable, intimate tables. The staff are all very friendly and helpful. The menu is expansive with many delicious meals to choose from. I went with the large Italian salad and it was so fresh and tasty. The prices were fair. I will definitely come back to this spot!

Never disappoints. I don't come here very often but when I do, I'm probably gonna get a salad. Sure it's weird, but they happen to have really epic Italian salads. The muffuletta salad is jam packed with deli meats you find on a traditional muffuletta on a bed of lettuce with lots of olives and a lovely vinaigrette. The pasta salad is so amazing I can't believe I hadn't tried it sooner - a huge portion, lots of meat, cheese and olives, and the same Italian vinaigrette that comes on the muffuletta salad. I saw they have a special with a muffuletta and a small portion of pasta salad and that will definitely be my next order. Honorable mention is their seafood lasagna. When they have it - get it. White sauce, plenty shrimp, delicious. Counter service is always great, food comes out quick for lunch, and they have a nice little patio on the 3 days we can sit outside for lunch. It's a must in mid city!

First time at Anthony's Italian Deli, and it was great! From the moment we walked in, we were treated like family by the friendly and kind staff. The service was top-notch, attentive, and made us feel right at home. And that's exactly what this place feels like - home! The quality of the ingredients is evident in every bite, and the food is simply delicious. My wife and I ordered the Godfather and the Marie sandwich, and they were amazing! The flavors, the freshness, the portion sizes... everything was just perfect. What sets Anthony's apart is the love and care they put into every aspect of the dining experience. You can tell they're passionate about what they do, and it shows in the food, the service, and the warm atmosphere. We can't wait to come back and try more of their incredible dishes. If you haven't been to Anthony's yet, do yourself a favor and get there ASAP. You won't regret it! Grazie Anthony's for a great experience!

Where do I begin with how often these places !!! it is the most authentic Italian place in the area. The food is absolutely amazing in every regards. I have never had a bad meal here, ever !!! Ultimate go to lasagna. It is the absolute best lasagna I have ever had. And I actually lived in the city near Little Italy, for many many years and this lasagna blows all of their away. Bring the whole family and enjoy the best Italian food you will ever have !!! The portion sizes are very generous, and the staff is always friendly and willing to help you with a recommendation !!! And on a sidenote. This place has the best muffaletta in town.

Excellent food. Try the meatball or Italian Lovers poboy. Muffslettas are great. Pasta dishes are wonderful. Great desserts.

First timer and I can't wait to go back! I saw this deli in the Baton Rouge 225 awards, and I thought I give it a shot... so glad I did! Right on Government street, it was so easy to find with plenty of parking around the buidling. Right when I walked it, I knew I was in the right place! The closet place to an Italian Deli that I have seen since moving to Baton Rouge. Such an authentic feel to it. I got The Godfather poboy and it was delicious and tasted so fresh. You could either choose from a large size or a poboy size. There were plenty of sandwich options too. I got mine to go, but there were plenty of tables inside and outside... all covered with red and white plastic cloths, just what I would expect in an Italian restaurant lol! So good and can't wait to bring my parents back here!

The food is amazing and the staff was friendly. I would recommend the Italian poboy.pool.

Anthony's is a gem of a place. After hitting New Orleans and seeing the Central Market has been destroyed and is no longer in business (for now), we were dying for Muffuletta. We were heading to one of our places to visit and along the route my daughter found Anthony's Deli listed as having incredible Muffuletta sandwiches. Well let me tell you something. THIS is the real deal and it rivals the Central Market. The proportion of meats to olive spread and the bread were incredible. The staff were fantastic and they have indoor and outdoor dining with a nice shaded patio. Everything about this sandwich was wow and if you are within range of Anthony's take a detour and have the best Muffuletta I have ever had. 5 stars

This is a fun little family deli. The sandwiches are delicious! They have some plates, Julie always gets the spaghetti and meatballs! They have take and bake dishes and you can buy deli meats and such. Everyone behind the counter greets you like family and there is outdoor dining if you would enjoy that also. I imagine that place is swamped at lunchtime, we usually go later.

Delicious like I remembered!! Thank you, customer service was also amazing. Good stop.

I love Anthony's. I've been eating at Anthony's back when they were located on Florida blvd. I had their 1/2 Muff special which comes with a half muffuletta and a salad. The service has always been great, and the food is amazing. I always struggle to decid to get either a muff, spaghetti, or the meatball po boy.

I go here often to get Italian specialty meats to make muffuletta sandwiches. The also have frozen meals you can take home and bake. What I've had was tasty but I mostly come for the deli meats

The food is SO good. The staff is all incredibly friendly as well. I forgot a sweater there over multiple days and they recognized me when I came back looking for it! Love this place

Pros: Pasta salad was 10/10. Cons: Staff wasn't very friendly. Charged $2 to add tomato to pasta salad.

Moved to the Mid City area recently. Been trying out the many new restaurants in the area as I lived across town for the last 2+ years. Stopped in for lunch one day and had the meatball poboy. It was very good. Friendly staff. Plan on going back again soon.

Still a classic and never disappoints! Have to add that the limoncello mascarpone cake is now a must-try! Perfectly light and sweet.

My wife's friend told her this is the best mufaletta in town. The sign out front says so, too. And it IS really good. Different than others I've had. The bread is nice and toasty (appears to have been mashed in a press) and there is a bit of spicy red pepper in the olive salad. Gives it a nice kick. Not the thickest layer of meat you can get, but plenty enough to fill you up. (Can't speak to service and atmosphere except to say that drive through service during the coronavirus quarantine is quick and easy. I hope to be back another time and try some other menu items - even if it is all the way across town)

This was our first stop at Anthony's Italian Deli. It has a very eclectic vibe with lots of it's history hanging on the walls. It's a family owned business, and we loved the feel. There appeared to be many regulars there, which I viewed as a good sign. Everyone seemed to be enjoying their food, and all looked good to me. We decided to split a muffuletta. First, it is absolutely HUGE. I could only eat about 1/4 of a total sandwich, and we had to bring some home. The taste is awesome, and the cheese was melted perfectly. I'd get it again anytime I'm in the mood for one. We will absolutely be back and highly recommend them!

Fantastic food, giant muffs, even the oil and vinegar dressing for the pasta salad side (which is enough for a meal) was molto delizioso! Reminds me of our neighborhood Italian deli when I was a kid, local stuff on the walls, boxes of products for sale...fantastico! And everyone there is so sweet, especially Nonna and the girls! Didn't have room for dessert, but need to go back to attack the dessert case!

We absolutely love Anthony's. The meatball Poboy is my fav. Friendly service and the food is always top notched. We have been frequenting this eatery on Florida Blvd & now Government for years.

A great spot in br. I've had nothing but a good experience here. They staff is very friendly always nice. I've had the sandwiches and the lasagna. All were good. Definitely swing by and get them a try

As far back as I remember I've always wanted to be a gangster. But let's face it, I'm just an Irish hoodlum who couldn't pull it off. So I head over to Anthony's deli to evoke that Italian American gangster spirit. And does it ever come out. Sitting inside the small deli or outside on the terrace, absolutely crushing some meatballs or the Marie sandwich, I'm alive. For a small window of time, I feel like Freddy no nose and Frankie the whop might slide in and start talking about the next job. I love every second of it. Anthony's is quaint, and is predicated on a clear family tradition of incredible food, and the insane ability to make losers like myself feel like an absolute boss via a sandwich. How is that possible? What kind of dark magic is this? I'll tell you how it works. Their food is such a delicacy, and loved in such a way, and balanced so incredibly flavor to flavor, that it actually invokes imagination. Food that causes you to day dream. Auditory and visual hallucinations. Usually you have to get ahold of some drugs for that kind of experience. All you actually have to do is allow yourself to be transported to another dimension of Italia through their menu. I've had everything they make, and not one thing I don't like. Their food has helped me through cancer and chemo therapy. In fact, I believe that it is directly correlated to the fact that I'm in remission. This food cures what ails you. Give in....submit yourself to the wonders of Anthony's Italian Deli,

Got a chance to try this hidden gem and I kid you not, this place has the Best capresse, muffelata, and meat ball sub i've ever had in my life! They wasn't kidding when they said they were known for their muffelata and meat ball sub. I highly highly recommend this place! The owner was also super friendly too! And their Dark Coffee creme brulee was rolling too!

This place is way, way, way overrated. Average Italian fare, sandwiches aren't worth the price they charge. Disappointed.

Popped in while passing through. Hubby loves an real Italian deli. The Italian deli sandwich was amazing. Chatted with the owner a bit, great guy! Support local!

I stop in at least once every time I visit my hometown. Outstanding quality. Lunch specials offer good value too!

Take out lasagna is great Take out spaghetti Sause great Muff was a huge disappointment

This is a small quaint deli/restaurant . I've been meaning to stop by for awhile . I stopped and got the lasagna plate lunch to go it was $15 with tax . I was greeted when I walked in . They also sell deli products and products from Italy . I really wanted a muffuletta but they are huge which they offered half of one lol. I'll go back with my husband to try one . The lasagna was pretty good but the salad was delicious. Sadly the salad was extremely small. The bread was tasty and a nice size piece . All in all I will be back to try the muffulettas!

Unbelievable food. Great family ran business. Wonderful people working. The muffulettas are great. You can get take away trays for functions that will not disappoint!!

Great, traditional sandwiches. Cold cuts, meatball, muffuletta, you name it. Everything is amazing.

Solid Italian food at Anthony's! We came because we heard they had the best muffulettas in BR, which definitely could be the case! They were delicious. They serve them warm, which was different than other places. We ended up trying a few other dishes, such as the lasagna and the Italian sausage. All the food was solid and pretty authentic! We will be back for sure.

I have a new pit stop between Houston and New Orleans - muffuletta New Orleans style was awesome and would recommend Anthony's - maybe 5 min North of I-10 via College Dr...no surprises here and if I had a scale I would guess the whole (large) is at least one Lb of meats/cheeses/olive dressing and Anthony's secret sauce...give it a try - you won't be disappointed!

Lunch to go today and never disappoints ... DELICIOUS! We had the muffalatta with pasta and Italian salad. Can't forget the desserts ... limoncello cake, chocolate mouse cake and cannolis ... oh so good and service is always impeccable wether to go or eat inside.

This was our second visit to Anthony's. Even better than the first. Best muff ever! Friendly service and terrific atmosphere.

The muffulettas here are the BEST in Louisiana. Sorry New Orleans, but we've tried them all and these are without question the best. No contest. Being from Southern Louisiana, we grew up eating these wonderful Italian sandwiches. These tangy olive, provolone, mortadella, ham, and salami 8" round warmed sandwiches. The bread is made from an old family recipe and cannot be matched. The lasagna is fabulous and the tiramisu is the perfect finish. Call ahead 15 minutes for pickup. The stand alone restaurant is usually busy. It's a regional favorite. Highly recommend this casual place for lunch or to grab muffulettas to tailgate before a big game, fishing, or picnics. Tell Marco and his mom "hi" when you go in. They always treat you like family.

Always always impressed by Anthony's delicious food and amazing service! And don't forget to grab dessert it is 12/10!

Always friendly service which is a must for a complete dining experience. The food is authentically delectable. One day I'll force myself to eat something other than the Lasagna but it's hard to pass up the opportunity to taste authenticity. The Lasagna is legit with its perfectly textured sheet pasta and flavorful meat sauce. The ambience is quaint and has a family intimacy about it. Love it. Highly recommend.

Omg the muffulettas are so delicious...!!! We had the pizza items and the original muffulettas , We had some in the restaurant an we took some for the road too... must try also was the sausage with tomato sauce it was delicious... the only bad thing is the is only 1,600 miles away from us ... we had a road trip to new orlean... we live in Las Vegas ... but will definitely drive those mile to eat those delicious muffulettas

Great spot for fast delicious Italian food. You can't beat their muffulettas. Counter service. Usually crowded. Get it to go.

This might be the best sandwich in Baton Rouge. Definitely the best Italian deli sandwich in Baton Rouge. The staff is very welcoming, and it feels like a true Italian deli experience. Must try.

My entire family loves this Deli. Their food is always fresh, ready when you arrive to pick it up, and delicious when you get it home.

red sauce so good, you could drink it. LOVE this place. the lasagna plate is wed-friday i think and melt in your mouth amazing. but you literally can't go wrong with anything on the menu. the muffuletta & the meatball sub are my other favorites. the almond cream cake is also delicious. also offers fresh deli & frozen items.

I found out about Anthony's Deli through my roommate who told me about their famous muffulettas. I always been a huge fan of muffulettas in general so I had to give this place a try. The service was outstanding, very friendly, and informative about any questions you had about the menu. I got the muffulettas and all I could say was wow! The different meats along with the cheese and the olive salad was total harmony in my mouth. The bread itself was soft and truly complimented the sandwich with all the good stuff inside. I also got their Tiramisu which I have to say was easily the best I had in any restaurant to this date ! Overall I highly recommend Anthony's Deli !

Sandwiches are legit and packed with love..when you walk in you know you're in an Italian deli..if you know you know!

The best sandwiches in town. Baton Rouge has a serious No-Jewish-Deli problem on its hands, and, while this isn't a Jewish deli, the exact opposite, it's still putting out the best sandwiches and salads. The Godfather ‍

wanted to love the muffelatta, missed the mark for me, not sure if it was the bread, olive mix or minimal meat, Jason's is better, but wanted to love Anthony's. sorry, I'm sure there are better options, my friend enjoyed the Lasagna.

43 years later, I still need my Italian Lover fix. When Anthony was working the counter on Coursey Blvd., I would order the sandwich with that name and he would answer "Here I am!' He's not behind the counter on Government Street, but sometimes Miss Marie is (she got off a plane today and headed straight there and I got to put eyes on her) and the sandwich still makes my taste buds smile. I needed that today(Hurricane Ida evacuation from NOLA), so thanks to all the friendly staff in Anthony's.