Antonio's Pizza

This is a great pizzeria. From their Regular slices to specialty slices they are amazing. My favorite is their buffalo chicken rolls. Filled with chicken packed with flavor. Never disappoints always fresh!!

I had the best damn pizza from here delivered to me from DoorDash. I’ve never had hot honey until I tried the Pepperoni, Burrata cheese, fresh basil, and Mike’s hot honey!! The pizza just melts in your mouth as you take a bite!! This is true NY style pizza!! The slices are so big too!! Worth every penny I spent!! I’d order again and again!!

This pizzeria is the type of place rapidly disappearing In nyc. Fresh pies constantly coming out of the oven. They have a full menu. Their meatball parm sub was one of the best I have had in nyc. Definitely coming back for more !

From a pizza connoisseur, please believe me when I say this is the best pizza ever. And everyone here is so welcoming and sweet , thank you 🩷

I’ve eaten at Antonio’s several times now, and it’s one of my go-to slice spots in Brooklyn for a quick bite. The pizza is consistently delicious. The sauce has real flavor and is well-balanced. The crust is crispy on the outside but also not hard that it feels dry. They also have many of options, which I appreciate.

💯 A perfect slice! The crust is both crisp and chewy. Sauce/cheese ratio is exactly what you want. 2 slices and a soda were $10. Lots of seating.

Absolutely the best pizza in New York. Love this place! Highly recommend working out at Ctunch then going for a slice (or two!!) * Kidding * But yeah, support this place! Vintage realness. All being wiped out in this city. Great deal! Wont be disappointed. Short walk from Barclays & Prospect Park / Grand Army plaza

Mostly a takeout place with a few tables. I ordered the chicken parm sandwich. They didn't skimp on anything. The sandwich was large and filled with plenty of chicken. It definitely hit the spot! Last time I was in town, I got some single slices from them and they were delicious.

Crispy, flavorful, rather thick slices. Friendly service. (Some of the customers here seem sketchy, but that's not really the fault of the staff.)

Antonio's has great pizza. It's one of the few places that offers an 18 inch Deep Dish pizza with a variety of toppings and flavors. This was my first time placing a delivery order- I asked for a Sicilian pizza but they sent a Grandma Square pizza instead. It arrived hot and delicious- the basil was very fresh ! Love the sauce - not too sweet nor salty. Pretty good !

No nonsense NYC pizza place as it should be! I'm not usually an artichoke pizza guy but this slice nails it!

Heading to the Brooklyn Library and noted Antonio's "old school" neighborhood pizzeria so went in for a cheese slice. Was OK, thin but still doughy and not crispy crust. If you like garlicky sauces, this is a good one for you. Next time, I'd try a Sicilian or Grandma's slice to see if they're a better experience.

Always go to Antonio's in Brooklyn pizza is always fresh made super busy and you can grab a Jamaican patty while waiting .

Great local pizza joint. We were at Prospect Park and walked here for a quick lunch. Classic NY pizza. I had a slice of cheese and a Grandma's slice. Both were great. Service is NY efficient. A few booths inside to eat-in. We'll be back when back in the area.

Always come here before I head home for pizza I their pizza because it's fresh and the crust is perfectly thin not too much bread definitely recommend

Stopped here for a quick slice. Cash only. The pizza was good. Service was good. Buy 2 slices and get a free drink. It was so hot when I went the deal came in handy.

Very delicious pizza and the best part very crispy! Fast service and friendly staff. Very calm and chill space.

We consistently order pizza from here. Personally, I think the slices are great. Consistent quality, comes hot, good size slices. My partner (a true pizza connoisseur) says he wishes the crust was a bit thinner and crispier. Would love to try more from this place the next time we order!

Delicious! 2nd time coming to Antonio's and it still did not disappoint. I used to go to another pizza hole in the wall a few blocks a way but they sadly closed. Glad I found this place! My all time favorite slice is the "grandma style" (I say that because the other pizza place I went to made grandma style cut regular but here is square). Thin crust, fresh mozzarella, and very fresh light but flavorful burst of tomato sauce. Heaven in a slice. Also, my friends had pepperoni slices and loved it! There is a special for $9 if you get two slices of pizza with a soda. To my surprise on this visit, I found out they aren't just cash only. You can use a credit card if you spend a $10 minimum. Wish I knew that sooner but will take a advantage of that next time! As always, there is an ATM inside if you need it and they deliver as well whole pizzas.

A classic Brooklyn joint, with one of the most consistently delicious recipes in the neighborhood

Embarrassed to admit I found this neighborhood pizza spot 9 months after moving to the area... they have a 2 slice / can drink deal for $9. They have a minimum requirement of $10 for credit cards, but they accepted a credit card payment. The highlight here is the Margherita slice!!! Perfect base, sweet tomato sauce, just the right amount of cheese. The mushroom slice was average and not necessarily special. The Margherita though, absolutely delicious!

Spicy chicken was definitely a great choice Fresh and good size as well They had some good choices and seating area

No frills here, just absolutely the best Brooklyn style pizza in this neck of the woods - my backyard, BROOKLYN! A mom and pop type establishment with a mom and pop feel/vibe. I passed it by for years because am not a fan of Brooklyn style pizza. But not anymore... this is now my go-to for a nice crunchy crust, tasty all around - "more-ish"! Notable mention - they do offer a gluten free option. Plus I love and encourage supporting small neighborhood businesses.

This review is in response to Chris B posted on 1/10. The review that was posted was just shocking to me. I am the Puerto Rican woman that is mentioned in the review and I remember that day as if it was an hour ago. I'm a regular at Antonio's Pizzeria and have developed a great friendship with the entire staff because of it. I will not allow a negative review to be posted by someone who, (1) didn't know me, and (2) was their first encounter of our humorous banter and didn't grasp the full context so I'm here to clear the air. I'm unclear as to why he waited until I left the Pizzeria to say something rather than addressing it while I was still inside if he was so appalled. If it had been addressed while I was there, it would have been resolved immediately and this review would not be necessary. I can't say enough good things about the entire team. Did you know they have been at this same location for 66 years and closed only twice? Throughout the pandemic, they worked tirelessly. It is impossible to know this type of information without a discussion with them and building the rapport. Great guys, great Brooklyn pizza

Walked in randomly and got two square slices. DELICIOUS! I will be back. Its cash only but they do have an ATM inside.

Excellent pizza and service! They've got a bunch of different options and the slices are pretty big so I only had one - for now. I'll definitely be back for more! I had the lasagna slice and it was delicious. This was my first time having a lasagna slice and the ground beef with the ricotta just really made for a delicious flavor. The dough is a great consistency and overall a really well made thick square slice. The service was so, so friendly. I also appreciate that they are checking for vaccine cards here as some places have been slower to adopt. Made me feel much safer eating indoors! I will definitely be coming back.

The best pizza in this area hands down!! Not only is the food good and fresh, the customer service is impeccable!!

Ordered delivery and the delivery time was quick, pizza came still hot (though was just a little undercooked and oily for my liking). Solid flavor, good size and good price. Would order again if craving traditional ny slice. Buffalo chicken roll was a bit underwhelming.

One of the Best pizza joints in Brooklyn. Catering is AMAZING! Dishes are phenomenal!I've been going here since I was 5! 30 years later, it's still my go to anytime I'm back in park slope. Service is always kind. Intimate setting! They treat me like family!!

Good pizza great sauce nice staff overall 9/10 coming from queens this spot competes with some of my local favorites

THE BEST casual pizza joint in Brooklyn - the Fresh Mozzarella grandma's pie is unbeatable.

Excellent food Outstanding service We love all their food Regular customer Absolutely delicious

Going here for 40+ years. Watched guys there grow up. Consistently satisfied with all their food and great plain or grandma slices are go tos.

Antonio's is my go-to pizza place. The by-the-slice options are extensive and whole pies are always delicious and generous. Well priced and worth every penny.

Pizza: Artichoke slice - excellent flavor, good crust, prefer this over artichoke pizza franchise Margherita slice - a bit thicker than I expected for a NY style slice. Cheese was excellent and generously portioned. Crust was average, very small crust edge without much flavor. Sauce was top notch, very flavorful. Would have liked a few pieces of fresh basil on my slice but did not get that. Service - some of the nicest guys I've ever met in the pizza industry. I did not have exact amount of cash for my order and the person told me not to worry about it and just come back when ever I'm in the neighborhood to pay them back. Will be coming back here many more times to try all of their options.

Definitely a notch above your average pizza joint. For instance, a mushroom pizza slice is made with fresh mushrooms, not canned, and has a dusting of parmesan on top. This is the place to go for pizza in the neighborhood, and they have that great neon sign, classic!

I only had a vodka and a regular slice but it was amazing. definitely not from the area at all but the hospitality was also great. nice people and my food came very quick. my father is from the area and he was impressed on how their pizza is still out of this world. definitely recommend 100%.

The flavor was great, the slice not so much. It was super hot and then proceeded to fall apart as I ate it. That said - it tasted great. The place itself is cool. Staff was friendly enough.

In the city that never sleeps, there are many pizzerias. They all make claims of being the best, but one stands out. This little unpretentious gem on Flatbush Avenue in Park Slope is tops for anything on the menu: Pizzas, salads, pasta, calzones. It's not some fancied up place, but the food is to live for. You will not find better.

The pizza is average and the music acts they host there abysmal and loud enough to be heard for blocks awayu. Unfortunately it seems most of the review are from people outside NYC who may not know there are several superior pizza places - Figlia Wood-fired pizza on 24th Ave, Samaria Pizza (great for take out or grab a quick bite) on Broadway and 21st Street in the mini-mall, Vite Vinosteria is a beautiful restaurant on a quiet little area of 34th Street serving excellent Italian food, drink and pizza, you won't have the local fire truck or ambulance blaring its horns as happens with Sacs which is located on an avenue favored by police cars and ambulances. Sacs is best during the wintertime for indoor eating but it is not the best. Maybe if it were in some place like the remote western panhandle of Texas.

Great Customer service. Love their sausage, onion, and pepper slice. Their slices have a nice tasting crust.

Disclosure: This review is brought to you by an Italian that grew up in Bay Ridge, Brooklyn. This place is OK if you're looking for a quick bite. Like their red sauce (it's sweet) but they can definitely work on their crust and premium slice options. For any pizzeria to not have a vodka slice option, that's a negative in my book.

Picked up a grandma pie tonight for dinner with friends in the garden of my building. The grandma pie was delicious - got half pepperoni, half regular. Worth walking a couple of extra blocks to get a pie or slice at Antonio's.

This was my go-to when I lived in the area. I now live far away, in a different state, and I would give up every single "nice" restaurant in my neighborhood for a single taste of antonios. The pizza is perfection, the pasta is perfection. it is no muss, no fuss, just pure delicious. You know its good because they don't need to update any of the decor, or change the signage. Its perfect. Ignore all the fancy places and go here.

Great pizza for a great price! My boyfriend and I got 3 special slices and a regular which came with two sodas for free for $17. There's a decent amount of seating if you want to eat your slice there too.

Loved the sauce, good amount of cheese, just wish the crust was a bit crispier. Solid plain slide, really loved the square tomato slice with garlic chunks.

After offending a woman with regards to her Puerto Rican heritage and openly admitting to offending her, a male employee working the register commented to his coworker that he was not looking for a woman with dreams, stating that she would have to wait until her next life for them to come true. With the pizza slice on the counter having been just heated up, I asked for my money back and don't plan on going back.

We were looking for some good pizza options near Prospect Park, and stumbled upon this place. They do serve by the slice despite it not appearing anywhere on the menu, with the quality of each slice varying quite widely. The margherita pizza was my favorite, with nicely made clumps of tomato sauce and a very garlicky overall taste. The other pizzas though were a bit more mediocre, with the all pepperoni slice being kind of sad (to the quality of the dipping closer to those 99 cent pizza places). Still not a bad choice for the area, and its close enough to the park that you can buy a pie and walk over and eat it there.

My friend saved me 1/10th of a garlic knot from here and it was life-altering. Best I've ever had 10 /10

Great old fashion pizza parlor great regular slice definitely worth a try loved the ambiance old Brooklyn

Was recommended to Antonio's pizzeria from a friend and was not disappointed.. awesome service .. would have to say definitely best pizza i ever tasted..guys behind the counter awesome and funny felt very welcomed .. wish they deliver where I live in but definitely worth the travel .. can't wait to go back thanks Antonio's

I've been coming here for a very long time and I am always satisfied with not only the amazing food but also the wonderful staff and service! Their food is always fresh and delicious. Would definitely recommend the vodka slice but you could also never go wrong with their regular slices as well. If you're looking for a quick and delicious bite, you should definitely check out Antonios, you won't regret it!!

Our favorite big family dinner catering place. Everything is flavorful and excellent value

Classic spot, since 1957, Antonio's Pizzeria looks just as it did back then, with it's large neon signage and of course, it's classic quintessential NY style pizzas. The pizza reminded me of the pizza I had growing up in Brooklyn during the 1980s, lots of herbs in the zesty, juicy sauce, delicious, salty, funky mozzarella and a light, crunchy crust that isn't too tough on the chew. This is the way all NY pizza used to be, back before it became a fast food; before dollar slices and high volume pizza.

The Grandma's pizza was really good even with a thinner crust than I'm used to. I've been looking for a good place for a slice and I think I found my spot!

Best grandma slice/pie I can find in NYC. Everything else they do is brilliant. Love the neon sign, old school New York vibes inside. Killer pizza -- worth the trip in my book. So happy they survived the pandemic.

Very good pizza! Not at all greasy ... which was very welcome. They handled my No cheese on half the pizza request... which I very much appreciated. The eggplant was breaded and very tasty that they put on the pizza. The pizza came well ahead of the expected time , which was very welcome!