Brenda P.
Yelp
I moved up AQ to the very top of my (long) list of "must try" restaurants because I have always been a fan of Chef LoSasso and The Forge. From what I read prior to my visit, I knew this was supposed to be different and that he would still be experimenting with the dishes on the menu. The end result for us was disappointing.
Arrived at the magnificent Acqualina on a Saturday night. STUNNING! Hospitality and service started the second they opened the door to our car. The hotel and restaurant staff was extremely welcoming and courteous. Checked in with the hostess and after a brief wait for our new table (we did not love the location of the first table they gave us), we finally sat down. We were very eager to begin our AQ experience, but the waiter took a while to open our wine and come by for our order. The restaurant was not very full. I am not sure why there was a hold up. When he did come by the table, he was always very pleasant and agreeable.
The restaurant itself is very beautiful. I especially loved the palatial ceiling and perfectly fitting chandelier. Inside, you will also find seating at an eat-in bar (separate from the main bar for drinks) with oceanfront views due to its elevated location and a walk up counter for dessert and coffee. This counter can be accessed without ever stepping in to the actual restaurant. The picturesque outdoor terrace (perfect for cooler days) is right out of a magazine. Red cushions dominate the entire outdoor seating area. All of it is anchored by a large fountain in the center of the space and overlooks the hotel pool and beach.
Back inside, once we finally placed out appetizer order, we were served hot doughy basil/cherry bread. Our food order was as follows;
Ceviche- this did not look very pretty, but it did taste good. Not the very best I've ever had, but very enjoyable.
Green Eggs and Ham- I love me a clever name and theme. This dish delivered! The green part, as expected, does not look very appetizing, but it does taste great. Eggs, chives, Ibérico ham and a little mascarpone on top. I wish it was hotter upon arrival though.
20 Hour Charred Octopus Crostini- I liked this more than the hubby did. The only problem I had with it was the quantity. It's definitively enjoyed better as a one person appetizer and not shareable. The amount of octopus is minimal. The accompanying olives were unlike anything I have ever tasted, almost crisp. Not sure what made them that way but I dug it.
Chicken and Basil Meatballs- These were extremely dry. We kept dousing them in the accompanying tomato porcini sauce. The sauce, on the other hand, was delicious.
Seafood Bucatini- I only had a bite of this, but it was just OK to me. The hubs seemed to enjoy it though. It had scallops, shrimp, tomato and ......avocado? I thought that was an odd addition to the pasta. But hey, I love avocado and the husband doesn't so I stole all of it off his plate. I asked for some cheese (yes, spare me the "seafood and cheese don't mix" lecture), but we never got it. Oh well.
Three Mushroom Risotto- I had a couple of bites of this entree and I think it was perhaps the best of the night. Perfectly cheesy and with a great texture.
Pizza AQ- I know, I know, pizza? Yes, pizza. I will have you know that if you cross the street, Chef Timo's has one of my absolute favorite pizzas. I die for their black and white pizza! We ordered this one with tomato, extra mozzarella, Ibérico ham and pepperoni. Was it good? Sure! Memorable? nah. Just pizza. What's not to love about cheese and bread?
Grilled 10oz Creekstone Farms Burger- BIGGEST. SHOCKER. I hate saying it, but I have to. This was just so PLAIN. It was an unseasoned piece of meat. The cheese (3yr old aged white cheddar) added nothing to it. Nothing. We had them split the burger in half and I think I might have had 3 small bites of it. My friend might have left her half after the first bite. The accompanying crispy fries were perfect. I had ordered the truffle addition for the burger. At $8 there is no way this was real truffle. I am not sure what it really was, but it "seemed" like battered and fried mushrooms topped with truffle oil. Shoulder shrug. Sigh.
S'mores Ice Cream- DELICIOUS! I should have had more of this.
Chocolate Ice Cream- GOOD.
Dulce de Leche Donut- I liked the cakey consistency, but where was the dulce de leche? Certainly, NOT inside this donut.
Hazenut Donut- Dry. Awful.
Guava Cake- Not for the faint of heart because it's extremely sweet and decadent, but oh so good. Mmm, mmm, mmm!
Oreo Cheesecake- Good
I was really expecting a little bit more dazzle and wanted to be swept off my feet. I wasn't. I once attended a Caymus pairing dinner at The Forge (with Chef LoSasso) that I STILL talk about. There was none of that pizazz here. Nada. I realize the restaurant is not even 3 months old yet and it's because of that I might give it another go later this year. We shall see...