Michael C.
Yelp
Recommended by a dear old friend of mine for a reunion of four great friends from college and a birthday celebration, I discovered this new hidden gem in the quaint suburb of Winnetka. What a remarkable night of supurb Greek Cuisine full of outstanding flavors, bright, open atmosphere, and impeckable personable service.
My wife and I were the first to walk into Avli for our 8:00 reservations for eight of us. As usual, I like to arrive early to new places to get a feel for the atmosphere. As soon as we walked in, I knew we were in for a special evening. Bright, open, crisp atmosphere with three large dining rooms of tables with white table clothes perfectly spaced out for their guests to have a comfortable experience. A brilliant brick walkway towards a beautiful display of their wines in an open wine cellar, and a quaint comfortable bar where we enjoyed a glass of Rose in their nice Avli sketched wine glasses.
As soon as we all were together, we were seated in the middle of their main dining room and our server was quick to help us out with a great bottle of The Prisoner for our red wine choice and his recommendation of one of their Greek whites, which turned out to be a crisp version of Pinot Grigio. We already felt our "happy place" for the night and the atmosphere alone set the tone.
Great beginnings with our appetizer orders of Saganaki to split, tasty home made Eggplant Salad and Hummus with some of the freshest soft Pita I think I've had. Not sure where this originated from, but we really enjoyed their Watermelon and Feta Salad to split, something I did not see on the menu. If Saganaki was a "health food", I would of devoured theirs by itself. What a nice citrus bite to it.
The menu is so diverse and organized with a great variety of beef, lamb, chicken and seafood dishes. In addition, Avli has a couple pasta and Vegetable dishes to chose from. We all ordered differently, but when I go to a Greek restaurant for the first time, it is Lamb for me.
I ordered the Braised Lamb. Nice portion of tender, fall off the bone meat with the juices just flowing out of it. Most tender piece of Lamb, just how I like it served with oven roasted potatoes on the side. The flavors I have not had in most Greek restaurants anywhere I've been.
My wife had the Lake Superior White Fish with a perfect and not overbearing lemon sauce. I could taste the natural flavor of the Whitefish, which some places take away with crusts and sauces.
What a great presentation of their Salmon wrapped in parchment paper, my friend ordered. When the parchment was pulled back, the Salmon had a nice juicy glaze to it, probably from the ouzo baked over it. I never tasted it, but next time I will have to try this.
Everyone loved what they ordered. A beautiful Mini Rack of Lamb split between two of us, and what looked to be a nice, helping of Makaronia, semolina pasta with EVOO. We also ordered a beautiful and tasty yellow and red beet salad. Colorfully fresh and was delicious.
In regards to the variety and the preparation of the menu at Avli, this part of the experience could not have been better. Most of all, each dish stood for itself as best prepared as one can find in any Greek establishment. The flavors were MAGNIFICENT, and the presentation did not lie.
Our server did an incredible job, although the kitchen did not have my entree of Lamb out on time, but I was ok, the dish was fabulous. Never a glitch in the service, in fact he was friendly and informative and added to our special evening.
If anyone ever recommends Avli Estiatorio, take their word, because I walked away with a new hidden gem I would take people back to. The atmosphere is bright and happy, the flavors were top notch and they never missed a thing here. What a great reunion of friends because of it.