Jeffrey S.
Yelp
I've grown stuff from Baker Creek in previous years, and will do again this year. But for whatever reason, I hadn't yet made a purchase until this year. Oh, I for sure have known about them for years, and have swapped seeds for some of their stuff. And I definitely have seen their catalog--if you haven't read through the big catalog, or their for-purchase "Whole Seed Catalog" then you're really missing something.
So this year, I got on it early (as the last year and this have been wild in the seed business) and made my order. When I ordered, they said it could take up to a month, but I got my shipment in about a week.
Now, I will need to update this review after the growing season, but I order from a few different sources, so here's what I know right away after years of growing their stuff and from shopping incessantly all winter.
First, the popular stuff goes fast. Despite the very shiny marketing and the very interesting descriptions, they are not a massive operation and you need to order early.
Second, they like the weird stuff. I like the weird stuff. It's a good match. But if you're a beginner gardener, you might want to pick the normal stuff, or use a supplier that sticks to the normal stuff. The weird stuff is often (but not always) a bit more finicky to grow. I think it's worth it, but I like the challenge sometimes.
Third, you need to take everything you read with a grain of salt. Like fishing lures that are designed to catch fishermen, it is well understood in the garden seed world that marketing is over-the-top. Sometimes with their stuff, because it's weird, you need to read between the lines. If something has "a subtle flavor" that means it doesn't taste like much. If something is "really prized for its taste in XYZ country" it means you may not like it at all. I love this about seed catalogs and this is not unique to Baker Creek, but they really exemplify this trait.
We'll revisit at the end of the growing season to see what we learn, but I'm way excited to have some incredible new seeds to add to my growing, growing collection.