Carlos A.
Yelp
This is specifically a review of the wine dinner on 8/29/25. At $110 dollars per person, I think this is a fair place to put it even though the experience may not full reflect the regular experience at this restaurant.
Food:
Amuse bouche, prosciutto and melon: standard, nothing super special here, tasted fine but not a super premium prosciutto.
Antipasto, tortellini in brodo: the broth was supposedly "finished in aromatics" but I couldn't taste anything. It just tasted like cooking oil and a very light stock. The tortellinis were ok, a little doughy, and while the filling was ok it overall reminded me of the most okayest onion perogies.
First course, lamb with Italian chimichurri and crispy polenta: one small lamb chop that was thin enough that it would be hard to reach a satisfying medium-rare temp. It was cooked decently enough considering but didn't have a real sear. The polenta was cooked well and had a very satisfying texture, just wish it had a bit more flavor throughout. The Italian chimichurri was good!
Second course, crispy duck with red and yellows beets, beet puree, and asparagus: the beets and asparagus were great, perfectly cooked and flavored. The beet puree was divine, I absolutely could have drank it like a soup or smoothie; the highlight of this meal for me. However, the "crispy" duck had the lightest of sears on one side only and overall resembled something boiled. When paired with the sauce it was edible but otherwise was pretty off putting as the skin and fat was a bit overwhelming. The meat had all the gaminess of duck presented full-force; this was decently offset by the sauce but I feel like the duck should have been much tastier solo. I did not finish the duck meat.
Dessert: tiramisu with limoncello soaked lady fingers: this was fantastic. The chef-in-training (the sous chef for this meal was responsible for the overall menu and is currently attending CIA) definitely has potential as a pastry chef because this thing was delicious. Perfectly sweet whipped cream, a beautiful candied lemon slice, and a great homemade limoncello that soaked the lady fingers with just the right intensity.
Unfortunately, me and my fellow diner were left hungry at the end of this meal.
The wines overall were ok with maybe only one standout. I won't detail in review as I don't drink regularly anymore and only tasted each wine. Based on my fellow guest's reaction; the wine did not quite compensate for the okay-ness of the food.
The service staff were very attentive and appropriately friendly. The pacing of the meal was too slow. Other guests did not seem bothered as the wine was able to occupy their time but 20+ minutes between 4 small courses with speeches etc was too much pomp and circumstance for the experience provided.
Based on this experience, I would struggle to justify revisiting this restaurant based on the underwhelming nature of the food. I would weigh this against the fact that this was a special menu made by a chef in training but I would need some convincing.