Bennett's Sandwich Shop

Sandwich shop · Fenway

Bennett's Sandwich Shop

Sandwich shop · Fenway

4

1348 Boylston St, Boston, MA 02215

Photos

Bennett's Sandwich Shop by null
Bennett's Sandwich Shop by @TheInfatuation
Bennett's Sandwich Shop by null
Bennett's Sandwich Shop by null
Bennett's Sandwich Shop by null
Bennett's Sandwich Shop by null
Bennett's Sandwich Shop by null
Bennett's Sandwich Shop by null
Bennett's Sandwich Shop by null
Bennett's Sandwich Shop by null
Bennett's Sandwich Shop by null
Bennett's Sandwich Shop by null
Bennett's Sandwich Shop by null
Bennett's Sandwich Shop by null
Bennett's Sandwich Shop by null
Bennett's Sandwich Shop by null
Bennett's Sandwich Shop by null
Bennett's Sandwich Shop by null
Bennett's Sandwich Shop by null
Bennett's Sandwich Shop by null
Bennett's Sandwich Shop by null

Highlights

This cool Fenway spot serves up delicious Maine-style sandwiches, with must-try lobster rolls and hearty subs perfect for game days or picnics.  

Featured in The Infatuation
Featured in Eater
Placeholder

1348 Boylston St, Boston, MA 02215 Get directions

bennettssandwichshop.com
@bennettssandwichshop

Menu

Information

Static Map

1348 Boylston St, Boston, MA 02215 Get directions

+1 857 239 9736
bennettssandwichshop.com
@bennettssandwichshop

Menu

Features

dine in
takeout
delivery
payment credit card
Tap to pay
reservations

Last updated

Jul 7, 2025

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2025 Postcard Technologies, Inc.
@infatuation

"Lobster rolls are obviously great, but deciding between drawn butter or mayo can be stressful. You don’t have to do that at Bennet’s on Peterborough, because the roll here is made with both. This little counter-service spot should be where you go to stock up for a picnic in the Fens." - dan secatore

The 9 Best Restaurants In Fenway And Kenmore Square
View Postcard for Bennett's Sandwich Shop
@infatuation

"A couple doors down from El Pelon is Bennett’s, another place where you can fill up for not a ton of cash. It’s a sandwich shop that serves good 8 and 12 inch subs, one of which is a really good lobster roll that uses both mayo and drawn butter. But their breakfast subs may be our favorite thing in the restaurant, since one of them covers you for lunch, too." - dan secatore

Where To Eat And Drink Around Northeastern
View Postcard for Bennett's Sandwich Shop
@infatuation

"Bennett’s is a counter-service sandwich shop that makes a solid lobster roll with both mayonnaise and drawn butter. The whole menu is worth exploring beyond just the roll, though (try the cheesesteak). Head here when you want to grab a quick lunch in the neighborhood (they have tables out front), eat good food that’s a lot cheaper than what you’re going to get inside the ballpark when you’re going to the game, or are stocking up for a picnic in the Fens." - Dan Secatore

Bennett’s Sandwich Shop - Review - Fenway - Boston - The Infatuation
View Postcard for Bennett's Sandwich Shop
@eater

"In its simplest form, grilled cheese is true beauty. The version served at Bennett’s in Fenway — an import from Kennebunk, Maine — features toasted white bread and melty American cheese, and that’s all it needs." - Dana Hatic

Boston’s Best Grilled Cheese Sandwiches - Eater Boston
View Postcard for Bennett's Sandwich Shop

Kelli Bueker

Google
Delicious sandwiches! My Stegg Bowl was tasty! My husband’s steak and cheese was awesome…just a tad dry so get some sriracha aioli to add to it. Then it was perfection!

Ashley orf

Google
Buyer Beware if you order Uber Eats. Super disappointed they forgot my drink, siracha sauce for my fries and other side. I feel ripped off and overcharged. Will try to get reimbursed but not happy with my order:/ Dissapponted this is my experience after looking for top rated places in the area.

Genevra Applegate

Google
Conflicted in leaving this review but it is what it is. On one hand the steak was marvelously cooked, tasty, and not greasy at all; on the other hand though, Bennett's kitchen translated "grilled peppers and mushrooms" "provolone cheese" and "mayo" to "a HEAPING HELPING OF ONIONS (with a few mushrooms and peppers)" and "a smear of mayo." (No provolone cheese to be seen anywhere!) Tried to pick out as many onions as I could, but they were everywhere so basically, welcome to my gastrointestinal distress for the next 48 hours. (It's not like you can send back food via Uber eats at rush hour.) The fries were ok. Siiigh.

Meshia Brooks

Google
This is probably the best place to go to for a quick bite on Fenway st with how expensive the area is, I was trying to find something around ten dollars that would be filling but not huge at the pizza spots nearby they didn’t sell singular pieces of pizza and if they did two slices would be like 10 something and I was afraid it wouldn’t be filling I could’ve gotten a whole pizza for two dollars more but that’s too much food I came down here and was able to get this for 12$ the quality of the food is okay but the chicken tenders are giving Walmart brand and that’s okay MOST places that serve chicken tenders do but I’m used to being spoiled with my chicken tendys at chicken exclusive spots, over all this was a good amount of food they aren’t stingy with the side sauce, i got more protein then I would w the pizza and it’s more likely to keep me full all day didn’t get a drink cuz I had my own cook/staff seemed really organized which was cool

Corey Mooney

Google
Decided to try out the Burlington Mall location as I was hungry and they sounded good. Never heard of them before today, but was highly impressed. Decided to order the Wicked Chicken Cheesesteak, which was absolutely delicious. Got the small 8" sub and was blown away to see the portion size was closer to a foot. So portion size is amazing. The sub was loaded with meat and flavor. The crinkle cut fries were nice and crispy and the spice blend on them was quite tasty. Would definitely recommend this to anyone.

noodlenoggin

Google
I ate lunch here twice this week, because it's close to the office and I wanted a sandwich. It's right across the street from Fenway, if you're there for a game or something, so there's always that. I had the Italian and the Left Coast Chicken Cheesesteak. Both were good. Small is 8" and weren't what I'd call small. $19 for a sandwich and a small hash browns is pricey in the Midwest, but not really for an east coast city or across the road from a ballpark. Service was fast and reasonably friendly for Boston, no complaints. I'll probably end up eating a lot of lunches here while I'm on this project.

Samantha Medina

Google
Their famous steak and cheese subs are a FAV! I been in person once and the service I experienced was friendly and fast. I always order their subs on Ubereats and I’m never disappointed. The bread is so soft and has a nice taste to it. The steak is not oily at all so you get to enjoy a mess free meal and don’t have to worry about oil all over your face, dripping down your hand, or making the bread soggy and mushy. They do double cheese which makes the sub 10x better 🤤 I never bit into it and felt a fatty piece of steak which I appreciate cause it’s such a turn off 🫠 Overall I’d highly recommend Bennetts sandwich shop!

Amanda Maguire

Google
Definitely one of the best steak and cheese sandwiches I’ve had in a long time! The sub was packed with steak and had so much flavor! I did a takeout order and it was ready right when I arrived. There’s a decent amount of seats if you want to eat inside. Id love to go back and try some of their other sandwiches!