Cherylynn N.
Yelp
While we were eating at Blind Butcher, a guy casually walks by nekkid...full frontal and everything...and hardly anyone bats an eye.
Except the tourist couple whose jaws were sweeping the floor.
That's what I love about The Castro...if you got the balls to, anything goes!
Been eyeing The Blind Butcher since they opened in 2019 (sister resto to Dunya and Lark). And, my curiosity further grew with their hype on socials.
When Plan A fell through, Blind Butcher it is because last minute rezzies were very easy to get. But, rezzies weren't needed since it was pretty empty on a Thursday. So, if you're looking for last minute place for a weeknight dinner, Blind Butcher may be a good option.
Blind Butcher is open for takeout and dine-in. No delivery. Dog-friendly outdoor seating.
M E N U
Meat-centric New American Fare with a Greek flair. $20 bottomless mimosas for weekend brunch. Full bar.
D R I N K S
* Casamigos Blanco ($18 x2): https://tinyurl.com/24ayuf8k
Requested the tequila on the rocks but it came in a shot glass. I've never seen CB priced this high at $18/shot before.
F O O D
* Shishito Peppers w/ sea salt flakes, yogurt ($10): https://tinyurl.com/2rvd57et
Warm, slightly sweet shishito peppers (not spicy) paired with the cooling yogurt. Wish there was more blistering for a smoky dimension, but it was otherwise a fine starter.
* Mashed Potatoes w/ butter, garlic, paprika, olive oil ($10 x2)
Oddly listed under the apps/small bites section, we requested it to be brought out with the ribeye but it was still brought out as an app. The mashed potatoes were deliciously rich and creamy but you can tell it was cooked ahead of time and heated to order (lukewarm). We were hungry so we ate it and requested another round to come with the steak.
* Butcher's Wagyu Burger w/ bourbon caramelized onions, kasseri cheese, horseradish aioli, fries, ciabatta ($27): https://tinyurl.com/bdhspdau
--Requested medium rare
--Requested upgrade to truffle fries
Tasty, juicy patty with a sturdy ciabatta bun, cooked medium rare as requested. However, it was small and expensive compared to the bougie burgers at Nopa, Spruce, and Miller & Luxe that have a thicccer patty and same price point. I know wagyu is in its name but it's a buzzword that's loosely thrown around these days.
Instead of the truffle fries, we received regular fries dusted with old bay (?). They were ok and could have been hotter and crisper.
* 16 oz Prime Ribeye, rosemary-oregano marinated w/ chimichurri ($68): https://tinyurl.com/pwyn35kh
--Requested medium rare
Looked awesome and the medium rare was on-point! However, for being a marinated prime cut, it was quite chewy. I know it's shrinkflation times but Lolinda has a similar 18 oz ribeye for $52. The accompanying chimichurri was hella salty so I appreciated that it was on the side.
The ribeye includes several pieces of roasted potatoes, shishito peppers, and a tomato. Had we known this, we wouldn't have ordered another side of mashed potatoes.
S E R V I C E
Our server was nice and upbeat. Maybe it was an off day but service was too lax and lacked attention to detail. After we finished our meal, we had to go inside twice to ask for the bill...in a near empty restaurant (only one other table occupied).
Food service was fast; apps arrived within minutes of ordering.
A M B I A N C E
Cozy and sultry date night vibes with red banquettes and nice bar area. There's four patio tables in front.
P A R K I N G
Challenging street parking so give yourself an extra 15-20 minutes. No nearby garages.
Overall, I have mixed feelings about Blind Butcher. While they nailed the meat temps, I didn't think the food and service was commensurate to a $100 pp dining experience. IMHO, there's plenty of other places in the city you can better spend that monies. Glad I tried it once tho.