Victoria K.
Yelp
[NYC BOBA TOUR STOP #32]
*My other stops on the boba tour: https://www.yelp.com/collection/4dXTAnFqPHD1D8obaInTZw/nyc-boba-tour
Welcome back, Boba Guys! But also... maybe not that welcome? Jury's still out, we definitely did not come to a unanimous decision, so old boba guys lovers and new boba guys lovers alike will have to just come back and see for themselves whether or not it's still worth it.
Pre-COVID Boba Guys was excellent- it's something all of us can agree on, but it's like when Lucifer comes back from hell in season 5 and is actually Michael (can you tell I just finished watching Lucifer)- something is just a little off about it.
We ordered (rating): Strawberry Matcha Latte with Boba (4/5), Strawberry Jasmine with Boba (2.5/5), Dirty Horchata with Almond Jelly (3/5)
In pre-covid boba guys times, I tried a lot of different drinks here until I finally tried their Strawberry Matcha, which absolutely changed the GAME for me. The Strawberry Matcha is absolutely the best drink you can get here. And I know I'm saying this extremely confidently as someone who has only had a handful of their drinks, but I mean it. Every other drink (even the ones we had this time) always falls short. The amount that it falls short by differs depending on the drink, but it's always worse.
...And that is the main reason why this review is so mediocre as well. Consistency is so important in a boba shop- you can't just have one drink that stands above the rest. Every single one has to be good in its own way. Boba Guys has a ton of unique drinks (their menu has actually gotten larger since returning), but it's so hard to come here and pay $6+ for something other than the Strawberry Matcha when you have no idea whether or not it'll be good.
The other thing that was inconsistent even from drink to drink (which was insane) was the boba. While I found that my boba was good (strong albeit a bit too strong, sweet in itself), my cousin's boba was soggy and bland. My sister found that there was a strange aftertaste from the tea but blamed that aftertaste on the boba.
If you come here, get that strawberry matcha. Please.