Dominique J.
Yelp
Having long enjoyed the Bar at the Campton Place Taj, and enjoyed in the past their Michelin starred restaurant, I was curious to try the new Bombay Brasserie that has replaced the restaurant (which closed during Covid). Obviously, comparing this brasserie to the old Taj's wonderful restaurant would be unfair. They are two very, very different animals. I know there is a Bombay Brasserie in London that is very successful (I have not tried it); the English appreciate Indian cuisine (which is practically the first real cuisine they had ever been faced too), so I guess that British Bombay Brasserie is genuinely very good, and I expected to be agreeably surprised here at the Taj.
But I was a little underwhelmed with this San Franciso version. Indian specialties are good, albeit not exceptional, but other dishes are certainly not unforgettable. We had an Aloo Tiki, which was quite pleasant, a chicken Peema Parmentier that was OK, a Kashmiri Roganjosh that was good, a halibut that was a little bland. For dessert, we had a Gulab Jamun (two miniature pastries with a tasteless ice cream), and a uninteresting chocolate mousse.
I know this is a "brasserie," but real brasseries in France serve sometimes exceptional quality food, with a great, eclectic choice, and all sort of wines, beers and other beverages. The wine list here is anemic at best, and so is the desert menu -- with desserts that are neither imaginative, nor actually very good. As for the "dessert wines" list, it is also very limited and offers only half-bottles (no glasses!), and... well, champagne is not a dessert wine!
The service is not friendly, and much too stuffy for a "brasserie" -- even if it pretends to be somehow "elevated." Strangely, the staff of the old restaurant, which was excellent and not so stuffy (especially for a two-Michelin-star restaurant), was much more welcoming and friendly. The service was really the low point of this experience -- and the fact that, notwithstanding the time at which you arrived, the lights start telling you at 10:00 pm that you are expected to leave. I know that it is practically impossible to have a late dinner in San Francisco, but hospitality is what restaurants are meant to be in business for.