Tim C.
Yelp
I'm a big, big fan of Botiwalla at Optimist Hall. When I walked down the hall leading to the restaurant and smelled the aroma in the air, I knew I'd be checking the place out.
I ordered their lamb burgers with an SPDP appetizer. I had no idea what an SPDP was, so shoutout to my fellow Yelpers for posting helpful photos. It's a flour chip with yogurt, chutney, potatoes, onions, and cilantro, all topped with crunchy chickpea noodles. By the time I ate it, the chips were a bit soggy from the yogurt and chutney, but I enjoyed the flavors - a good mix of sweet and savory - as well as the lightness of the dish. I probably wouldn't get it again, but it was worth a try.
The lamb burgers are the bomb. The patties were cooked medium rare - which is perfection in my book - and the meat was so well-flavored. Spices galore. There was a burst of flavorful spices in each bite, and the slaw complemented the meat incredibly, adding a bite of crunch and some sweet and tangy flavor. The buns were soft and lightly toasted, and each bite was simply amazing. I enjoyed it so much I ordered a second round of them.
I got to try some of my friend's Vada Pav, which is basically like a ball of fried mashed potatoes / mixed veggies in a bun. Almost like a samosa-type filling, deep fried, then placed between buns. It was also very flavorful, but the lamb burgers were better, in my opinion.
The service was very nice and friendly, and we got our food pretty quickly after we ordered it.
We also came on an extremely busy Saturday evening at Optimist Hall where all the public indoor and outdoor seating was taken with multiple seat vultures everywhere. It was so refreshing that Botiwalla had plentiful indoor and outdoor seating for their customers, so we didn't have to try and fight the crowds for a table. For that reason alone, I would have come here, but the food is also excellent!