Michael Y.
Yelp
While fine dining establishments usually have some sort of history, culture or ambiance that elevates the experience of the restaurant, Chef's Table at Brooklyn Fare was a place that I was so impressed with the food quality, that without any prior hype, convincing, or even expectations, that I was still blown away with just the quality of food.
Besides having all the flair of beautiful plating and presentation, the food tastes amazing. Every dish was perfectly balanced with interesting or comfortable flavors, and made in combinations of flavors that were interesting yet easy to interpret. The ingredients were fresh, and it also carried to the dish, as I never felt an overbearing of too much fat, or dull flat flavors in any of the dishes. Everything was so lively, and I was excited for course after course throughout the evening.
If there was a part of the dinner that I keep coming back to, it's the broth. There are a few dishes with a sort of lighter fish broth, but it's so soothing, a perfect balance of acidity and flavor, and it really envelopes your entire mouth with a lingering deliciousness. On top of that, the chef has perfected the art of using oils from various herbs and vegetables. You'll see uses of many different oils that are made in-house, anything from green oils of ordinary herbs you might know, to exotic Mexican ones that you've never heard of. Their concentration and consistency in flavor, combined with the broth, produce an incredible and memorable taste.
Besides the broth dishes, some highlights from my meal included a green pea tart as the first starter. Not only were the peas stacked beautifully, but they were crisp and fresh, and the plentiful bite was a joy to work through and experience the soft pea texture along with all the complex flavors that went into prepping the peas. The mackerel nigiri was delicious, and honestly I wish there were a few more pieces of nigiri, as it was a very unique take on sushi and a very generous piece of fish -- really tasty.
Some dishes that were weaker to me included the biscuit of the uni dish. The uni itself was good (but not amazing), but the biscuit felt a bit out of place. I've had uni toast from Saison, and their bread is soaked and wet, but it integrates well with the softer texture of uni. The biscuit that Chef's Table presented seemed to stick out too much and was too rough for my tastes to pair with the uni. There is a very interesting looking cloud dessert dish, that was really cool and interesting to see the kitchen make it, but honestly I don't remember too much about the flavor. I felt like I was eating nothing (it's mostly air), and the experience was cool, but the flavor was forgotten pretty soon.
There is one part of my dinner that I did not like, and it was that I wasn't able to get my wine order in until I was already 3-4 courses into dinner. I had a guest sommelier on the day I was there, and I guess because he was called in emergency, it was harder to serve people? Still inexcusable to have the wine order delayed so much. I did end up enjoying a great bottle of a Riesling from Keller, but was still very disappointed that it came so late. Hopefully with the regular somm in the house, this would not be an issue.