Brooklyn Fare

I just had the worst and weirdest experience trying to purchase a poorly and wrongly labeled pasta and they made me look like I was the one reading it wrong, no sense of accountability. I spent over 10 minutes trying to pick the right pasta . Freaking 5 dollars pasta, not even an apology or a sense of accountability, they were looking at me like I did something wrong because I wanted to buy the pasta as it was labeled. No one asked them to do a promo, so I’m confused why they wouldn’t acknowledge or take accountability for wasting my time …

Two stars for convenience, but this place markets themselves as “high end” and then now refrigerates produce like tomatoes, onions + garlic. That should tell you all you need to know. It is true that their prices are high end I guess. Like other reviewers have mentioned you need an eagle eye and great memory because the listed prices often don’t match what shows up at the register. They will honor the listed price, but it happens so much it really feels intentional. It’s a shame because the store itself is very nice Edit: I added one more star because the onions, garlic + *most* tomatoes are back out of the refrigerated section.

Terrific grocery store with many great choices. Fresh cheeses, vegetables, meats etc.... Prices are reflective of a smaller shop, but the service is good. Nice bakery section and good produce section. Packaged food has many options. They have a nice selection of house made salads as well as a fresh salad bar.

Love this market! The food & produce is always fresh with lots of organic / specialty options. Their prepared foods are bomb too and I love their little charcuterie section!

Just like that…from 3 stars to 1 (should be Zero stars). So I went to Brooklyn Fare today. I saw this pistachio baklava that I wanted to try for the longest. It was much more expensive than I thought it would be ($6.99 for 6 little squares) but I just had to have it. A few mins later, while waiting for my food at Panera Bread, I decided to try my baklava. Thankfully I looked it over before eating it… there was MOLD all over it! It was only noticeable once I opened the container. I am soooooo disappointed. I had been looking forward to trying this for months. I called the store 3 times but the line just rang until I hung up. I am so disturbed by this…. Original 3 Star Review: The prices are way higher than other supermarkets. For example, I bought a 16oz bag of almond flour for $11.99. Another store had the same item for $7.99 & it wasn't on sale. Going forward, I will check other stores before going here...

Several packs of old cheese in bloated packages just sitting with the rest of the cheese. This brand of cheese is shrink wrapped so for the packaging to be puffy means bacteria has started created gasses inside the package. The cheese is also cream colored so for it to look partially black under the wrapper is horrifying. I tried telling an employee and was ignored. Taking into account the other reviews of old food and unsanitary practices, I won't be going back.

I'm so so so tired of items being overpriced, mispriced, or completely unpriced. They added scanners so you can check prices but they break constantly. Prices are high so not having pricing information is incredibly frustrating. I often have to leave checkout to change items or take pictures of posted prices. Often I have to go to a second store because I refuse to be extorted. I literally only go to buy mixers at the point.

Almost Everytime I buy food from the deli it is no good Lasagna had mold, I went to the store found another one on the shelf with mold pointed it out The deli manager put it back on shelf they are going to end up getting people sick