Buttercup Bake Shop

Bakery · Upper West Side

Buttercup Bake Shop

Bakery · Upper West Side

1

166 W 72nd St, New York, NY 10023

Photos

Buttercup Bake Shop by null
Buttercup Bake Shop by null
Buttercup Bake Shop by null
Buttercup Bake Shop by null
Buttercup Bake Shop by null
Buttercup Bake Shop by null
Buttercup Bake Shop by null
Buttercup Bake Shop by null
Buttercup Bake Shop by null
Buttercup Bake Shop by null
Buttercup Bake Shop by null
Buttercup Bake Shop by null
Buttercup Bake Shop by null
Buttercup Bake Shop by null
Buttercup Bake Shop by null
Buttercup Bake Shop by null
Buttercup Bake Shop by null
Buttercup Bake Shop by null
Buttercup Bake Shop by null
Buttercup Bake Shop by null

Highlights

Butter Cup Bake Shop serves up delightful treats like buttercream cupcakes and a limited selection of cakes in a cozy spot with friendly service.  

Featured in Eater
Placeholder
Placeholder

166 W 72nd St, New York, NY 10023 Get directions

buttercupbakeshop.com
@buttercupbakeshop

$1–10

Information

Static Map

166 W 72nd St, New York, NY 10023 Get directions

+1 212 350 4144
buttercupbakeshop.com
@buttercupbakeshop
𝕏
@MadButterNYC

$1–10

Features

Last updated

Mar 4, 2025

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2025 Postcard Technologies, Inc.
@eater

"Butter Cup Bake Shop is now open at its fifth Manhattan location. The bakery known for its buttercream cupcakes was started by Magnolia Bakery co-founder Jennifer Appel." - Emma Orlow

A Running List of New Restaurants That Opened in New York City, November 2022 - Eater NY
View Postcard for Buttercup Bake Shop

Jessica Yang

Google
This location of Buttercup is disappointing in its offerings compared to the Buttercup location in east midtown. The selection of cake slices is very limited. The space is very small and there is no indoor seating. The staff was very nice. The cake slice I got today was very moist and yummy. The slice is a great size for the price. Would come again, but I really wish they offered more, like the ube and the strawberry cake they offer at the other location.

Céline BODART

Google
Stepped in to check this place out since I’d never been inside. Opened at this location in 2022 but looks like the business was founded in 1999 and the original location at the time was in fact across the street on W 72nd. Buttercup Bake Shop’s founder, Jennifer Appel, co-founded Magnolia Bakery in 1996.

The_Razor_Leaf

Google
This shop features a lot of different desserts, ranging from cookies to cupcakes and even brownies (in addition to way more). There are seats outside of the store for you to sit at while you eat, and the employees are extremely friendly and helpful while you’re deciding what to buy. Would recommend.

Tammy Augustin

Google
Shawty that was serving me was really friendly. I tried the dark chocolate peanut butter frosting cupcake and it was good. They have a one or two vegan and glutton free options.

james james

Google
Last night I had an intense craving of old fashioned vanilla cake. I stumbled upon buttercup and I can say was the cake was phenomenal and it came with great customer service as he answered all my questions and even gave me some recommendations of his favorites.10/10 will definitely be coming back

Jessica Forsyth

Google
Cute little shop with a lot of variety. The vanilla bean cheesecake was really tasty and so was the pecan bar. Definitely will come back when I can.

Dianne Mckay

Google
Love the banana pudding which is to die for. Also, the strawberry cheesecake is the ultimate best pastry from this business!! I recommend anybody to purchase these two top of the world sweets!!

Ana Wu

Google
Al is the best!!!! Just like all his cupcakes and cookies🥰🥰 I’m happy for having your store around, they got definitely THE BEST Red velvet cupcake 😊😊😊