Buttermilk Bakeshop

Love Buttermilk! They have made the cakes for my son’s birthday parties (one cake was a Ninja Turtle theme and the other was Tails fr Sonic). Pricing was fair and cakes were beautiful AND tasty! Highly recommend !

I’ve been ordering cakes from Buttermilk Bakeshop for the past 6 years and any idea I have Katy goes above and beyond, exceeding my expectations every single time. Not only are the cakes literal works of art, but they taste amazing as well! I will never go anywhere else for my cakes!!

I have been ordering cakes, cake pops and cupcakes from Buttermilk for 5 years. I have never been disappointed. Both the sight and the taste are always amazing. I tried plain vanilla, rainbow, vanilla and chocolate, but the best in my opinion is lemon and chocolate cake. The combination has a special kick. Communication with the Buttermilk team is very nice and efficient. They are very responsive and they always walk you through the customization process with valued recommandations. The cakes/ cupcakes/cake pops are the highlights of each sweet table I make. I highly recommend buttermilk bake shop.

For the third year in a row, we ordered our daughter’s birthday cake from Buttermilk, and for the third year in a row it tasted and looked amazing! We usually get a rainbow cake, but this year we got a Milk & Cookies cake and it was a big hit with kids and adults alike. Not to mention the kitty cat design of the cake was just as we hoped if not better. Communication with Buttermilk was great and the cake was ready at the designated pick up time. Thank you for once again being a part of our special day!

I am extremely satisfied with the custom cake I ordered! The bakery was very responsive throughout the process, making sure all my requests were met. The cake was a hit at the party—everyone, especially the birthday girl, absolutely loved it. Not only was it beautiful, but it was also delicious. This isn’t my first time buying a cake here, and I can confidently say it won’t be the last. Highly recommend!

Such a great bake shop! Ordered my son’s cake and they were able to make a cake version of apple pie (his favorite) the cake and apple pie filling was so so tasty! Also got the Jojo’s Bizarre Adventure cake topper perfect! Only thing I would suggest is to have the outer icing be thinner, less dense. It was very thick and everyone left that part on their plate including my son. Would have been 10/10 with a nice soft frosting instead. Overall, I would definitely order again though with specific instructions for frosting! Thanks for making my son’s cake look amazing 💜

We ordered a two-tiered designed wedding cake in their “classic wedding cake” flavor, and it was absolutely delicious. We sent them an inspiration pic at the start of the process, and their work to make it a reality came out beautifully. Buttermilk Bakeshop was easy to work with in giving us a quick estimate and working with us within our budget. I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend them to anyone looking for a bakery for their wedding!

The cakes and cupcakes are divine! I ordered the honey pistachio cake for my birthday and my friends and I couldn’t stop talking about how exquisite it tasted. It was such a beautiful balance of flavours. I’ll also recommend the Coconut Cream Pie and Strawberry Shortcake cupcakes. Definitely 10/10