James L.
Yelp
I was in the area Sunday morning and decided to pop into the Call Your Mother Deli's location in Old Town Alexandria. Opened in early 2024, the Old Town location of the popular local chain specializing in bagels and coffee is certainly larger and more welcoming than their DC outposts, which are mainly focused on Takeout orders.
The tropical pink, teal, and yellow color scheme is prominent, with floral decorations throughout the interior. Plentiful seating, high ceilings, and exposed ductwork complete the modern design aesthetic. I greatly appreciate the ample seating, since it's always best to immediately enjoy a bagel when it's freshly toasted. I understand that it was a busy Sunday morning, but it took over 10 minutes for my order of two toasted bagels with cream cheese, to come out of the kitchen.
This is not to imply, however, that the Old Town CYMD also does not do a brisk takeout and food delivery business. The pick-up area for orders placed in-person and online, was BUZZZING with people as well as Uber Eats and Door Dash drivers picking up bags of bagels and cups of coffee. TBH, this area can get a bit crowded and chaotic as everyone intently listens for their orders to be yelled out.
While I'm generally underwhelmed by the bagels at CYMD, I will admit, that I appreciate the more unique non-traditional flavors, such as the toasted Za'atar topped bagel with cream cheese I ordered.
This Middle Eastern spice traditionally is a blend composed thyme, oregano, marjoram or a combination of the three, and can also include other spices including sesame, sumac, cumin or coriander. The bagel was properly toasted, and had a healthy shmear of cream cheese; note to other bagel shops which skimp on their spreads. The spice mixture adhered nicely to bagel and I also appreciated that their was some notes of salt. It was also great to sit at one of the tables outside to dine al fresco, while enjoying the cool early summer morning.
However - Insert snarky New Yorker's comment about the quality of DMV area bagels in 5...4...3...2...
Honestly, I've never been super impressed with the CYMD bagels. I think the bagels are too chewy and somewhat underbaked after the boiling process.
I mean, are the bagels here equivalent with what I find back in Brooklyn? IMHO, no they are not.
The prices to me, are also, a tad on the high side. Two bagels with cream cheese and 20% tip, totalled a shade over $12. If I had added some plain drip coffees, the bill would've easily tallied close to $20.
I dunno; seems a bit excessive to me. To be fair, prices are on par with what I find back home in NYC.
But in the DC area, eating bagels from CYMD is seemingly the bougie thing to do; almost like drinking coffee, while flashing a Starbucks cup circa early 2000's. I guess if you get a bag of dozen bagels for $24...that's not a bad deal since it comes out to $2/each.
For me, stopping into the Old Town CYMD will be an one-off occasion, and not a regular occurence.