Jereth Tolentino
Google
We finally made it to “Call Your Mother,” a spot that’s been hyped up everywhere I turn. Walking up to the bright pink awning and quirky name, I was already feeling the charm. The place has a fun, lively vibe with colorful decor, and it’s clear they put thought into creating a visually inviting atmosphere.
Now, let’s get to the food. The bagels themselves were good—definitely fresh and chewy in all the right ways. I had the classic lox sandwich on an everything bagel, and while it hit the right notes with the cream cheese, capers, cucumbers, and fresh salmon (as you can see in the photo), it didn’t completely blow me away. The sandwich felt balanced and well-made, but I’ve had better at some of my favorite local mom-and-pop bagel spots. My partner tried one of their breakfast bagels (with egg, cheese, and sausage), and it was solid too—hearty and flavorful, but again, not earth-shattering.
The staff was excellent—super professional, polite, and efficient. Even though the place was busy, they kept things moving smoothly, which is always a plus. But here’s where things fell short: the seating situation. Inside, it felt cramped, and there just wasn’t enough room to enjoy the food comfortably. If you’re planning to eat there, you might want to arrive early or be ready to take your bagels to-go.
For all the buzz this place gets, I was expecting something a little more extraordinary. It’s a good bagel shop, don’t get me wrong, but it didn’t live up to the hype for me. My local, no-frills mom-and-pop bagel spot still reigns supreme in terms of both flavor and value. That said, Call Your Mother is definitely worth a visit if you’re looking for a trendy, Instagram-worthy spot with good food and great service.
Final thoughts? This is a solid 4 out of 5 for me. Good bagels, great staff, and a fun atmosphere, but I wouldn’t go out of my way to return unless I was nearby. If you go, grab a sandwich, snap a photo, and enjoy the vibe—but manage your expectations.