Calogero's

Nice family friendly staff! Garlic knots were good but needed salt. Pizza was not worth the price. Pizza was very thin except the crust, which led to burnt areas. They added olives to the Capricciosa pizza (not in the website description) and it completely ruined the flavor. The America pizza did not have nearly as much protein as the picture on the website.

Love a good wood fired pizza and nothing beats a great Italian pizza! We came here hoping to reminisce of our time in Naples and it did not disappoint. The margarita pizza and Funghi pizzas were great- soft fresh sourdough crust, yummy tomato sauce, melty cheese. The pizzas were filling but light. It was a small but cozy indoor space but the staff was attentive and checked on us from time to time. We enjoyed and will be back :)

I was finally introduced to this place by my cousin and our friends. The pizza was cooked to perfection. I had the pizza bianco with artichokes. They even offer gluten free crust.The ingredients you can tell are fresh. I felt like inwas back.in Italy. The pasta was amazing and light. You definitely feel at home. If you want fresh authentic Italian Food..come too Calogeros . The owner Salvatore is a gem and takes pride in his cooking. You are missing out if you haven't already been!! Forza Italia

THE best pizza I’ve ever had! Period! Bar none! Authentic Italian Style Pizza! Fresh and wood fire oven roasted to perfection! Started it all with hot chewy & moist garlic knots and ended the nite w pistachio gelato and tiramisu🙏 I’ve been to Italy many times and I can honestly say this is just like going, but in Naperville. The best part of the whole experience is the staff! Ariana & Walder are the friendliest and best around ! Thank you and see you again🍷🍷

Salvatore, your food never disappoints!!! We’ve always ordered pizzas, today we wanted to have a different experience and decided to eat inside your place. Heads up, this is a 4 table place, which makes it even more special!!We ordered arancini, spaghetti (ragu) and orecchiette, and woww!!! you transported us back to Lucca and Cortona..mmm!! The flavors, the freshness, the texture of your pasta… delicious!! Thank you…

Best pizza ever! Great taste, fennel sausage is amazing, fresh basil, fresh mozzarella, and the CRUST is always perfect. Go try it...you will love it!!!

Pretty much the best pizza we've ever had. I hope this place stays in business 100 years. Love you, Calogero's!

Pizza was Excellent. Definitely will call back. New York style pizza was Chef Kiss 💋. Service is absolutely wonderful from Salvatore

Calogeros catered my sisters wedding and let me tell you, not only were they super responsive and on time, the pizza was a hit! The food was great and the service was phenomenal. I will definitely have them cater again!

OMG!!! This place is amazing!!! It has been so difficult for us to find a good Italian restaurant in the area..this ticked all the boxes! It's a small place with maybe 4 tables inside. You order at the counter and you can see them making the pizza which is pretty cool. The pizza is literally the best!!! We got the Pepperoni and inhaled it in minutes. We also got the penne alla vodka pasta...so good! We got the Cannoli for dessert- it was soo light and flavorful! Amazing!

Service was great, you order at the front and they'll bring your food to the table. Everyone was friendly and helpful. We got the burrata salad, the arugula was nice and peppery, the burrata was good, but not as creamy as I prefer but would definitely order again. Maybe ordering some prosciutto on top. We got the mushroom pizza, crust was perfect and mushrooms were nicely done and flavorful. An authentic wood fired pizza, one of the best in north Plainfield/Naperville area. The winner of the evening was the vodka pasta, the sauce was creamy and cheesy. Was so good we wanted to lick the plate. They have a strong carry out business as well. Find this hidden gem and have some great Italian food.

We had to stop in and try this place out because it was recommended by my favorite pizza man, whose opinion I hold in high esteem. The pizza here is very good. The flavor is legit and the portions on the menu are excellent. We had the pepperoni (with hot honey) and the carciofe (artichoke hearts and garlic on white pizza). I wish I could find artichoke hearts in more places. And it's real thin crust wood fired pizza. The people were really nice. Seems like a family run business. There is not much seating, but they come right out and wipe them down quick. And the Sicilian flag logo on the wall matched the Sicilian lemon and orange sodas. The Nutella calzone (with strawberries and bananas and powdered sugar) is unique and delicious. (Was enough for dessert for 4.) Although the filling could be dispersed more evenly. The restaurant business is tough, especially in the first year. I hope they stick around.

I recently tried Calagero's Pizza, and it was absolutely phenomenal! Every bite felt like a masterpiece, bursting with authentic taste that reminded me why I love pizza so much. It's clear they put a lot of care into their recipes, and the results speak for themselves--pure deliciousness! That said, I was disappointed to notice an unexpected "LOCAL fee" added to the bill. While I understand businesses may have certain costs to cover, this type of surcharge feels unnecessary and detracts from an otherwise amazing experience. I'd recommend rolling such fees into the menu prices to avoid surprising customers. Overall, Calagero's serves some true pizza but the billing practice just seems shady to me, it's a matter of principal, might or might not ever come back. Pizza is truly 5 stars but the fees are - 2 for me.

We had the sausage pizza and split a salad and it was excellent. East coast style pizza was the right size for 2 hungry people. We also purchased a fresh, out of the oven sourdough bread that they sliced for us. Wonderful Sicilian restsurant. Will definitely come back when in neighborhood.

They have the best sourdough bread in town, it's so fresh and delicious! Their pizza is very good too, and everything on the menu looks delicious. It's a small business, and it's better to support than a chain!

Sal has a passion for bread-making. Probably the best sourdough round I have had in the country and that includes the countless sourdough bread makers in SF. Pannatone was on-point. Pizzas are fantastic. The Sicilian roots come through ! Bravo!

OMG. What a great addition to this relative pizza desert of the Chicago suburbs! Real deal Neapolitan, beautiful sourdough crust, super hot oven, great ingredients, expert chef. With a little NYC attitude and the wisdom of Calabria. What more can you ask for? And real canolis with actual pistachio. Best you can have outside of Napoli itself. Clearly a family business with a commitment to the right way according to the Associazione Verace Pizza Napoletana. Can't wait to try every pie. Only thing more I could ask for is a nice corner slice from a square Sicilian pie...my favorite in NY. Get yourselves over to Calogero's immediately!

I'd like to give this place 10 stars!! Everything I've ordered here has been nothing short of amazing !! This place is a little gem !! Great job

Pizza crust was not crispy on the bottom but edges were fine. Traditional toppings cheese and sausage were ok. White pizza was better. Not going back when Chicago offers so many other good options. We were visiting from out of town but grew up in Chicago. One of the things we look forward to.

Delicious and authentic italian style pizza. Wish I'd found this place sooner! Best pizza I've had in this area.

The food was outstanding. We ordered the fungi pizza and vodka sauce pasta. The pizza was great but the paste was some of the best I've ever tasted. Very fresh and flavorful.

The Pontone has changed it used to be the best now it's terrible and small as a cupcake for 40 bucks. It's insane.

On the 15th/ Wednesday I was enjoying my last day with my daughter on her visit and we stopped by next door for some bubble tea, that place didn't have food so I came in here. I was greeted by a gorgeous man with some colored eyes (hello eye candy). I ordered a pizza and took it next door to eat and was blown away! This is some real authentic Italian pizza. I originally only intended to have one slice and my daughter wasn't going to eat, but we ended up eating the whole pizza in that sitting, lol. I'm so glad we stumbled on this place because this will be my go to pizza place now. The art on the wall was really cool also. This pizza is made fresh so I did understand when he said they didn't have single slices but if there was a way to maybe just pick the the top selling pizza to have available in single slices? I live by myself and would be more inclined to go more often if I could get a smaller size. And it would be nice also to have mozzarella sticks or some small side options. But again amazing pizza!! Thank you.

My husband & I came across a video of Calogero's on YouTube a couple of months ago and we had to come try out their pizza! Drove about 45 mins and it was 100% worth it! We tried their pizza, vodka pasta, arancini and garlic knots! Everything was 10/10. Owner was super friendly and made it a very personable experience even with my crazy kids running around! Also Coming from a Sicilian family loved all the decor! Will definitely be back along with some more of the family!

This is quite possibly the best pizza in Naperville. My wife thinks it's better than the new place in Downtown Naperville, Mia something? Go and pick it up and get it home quick though.

This is for delivery service only. Please, please, please do not get delivery here. I could tell if it was served in the restaurant it would have been very good. You can always tell by the crust. But delivered this was lower than room temperature - ice cold. I doubt they deliver or use a service that delivers with insulated carriers. I was a bit put off by the overdone burntness of the garlic knots but another photo of them here looks the same, so I guess that's normal.

DELIVERY REVIEW: Do not EVER order delivery. Your pizza is guaranteed to be cold. They use door dash and the drivers take forever. If the restaurant is going to continue to use door dash they'd be better off to not even offer delivery.

Real people real food real passion and love going into every bite. Love seeing places like this and meeting the owners

This is an amazing little pizza place! We love pizza and are always looking for the next best place--well, we found it. The owner is a super-friendly guy and the quality of the pizza is outstanding. We tried the Salsiccia, garlic knots, and a cannoli. The garlic knots were unbelievable- the dough was amazing and had the right blend of oil and garlic. I could have made a meal out of them. The pizza was equally impressive- the right balance of quality ingredients. It even tasted good the next day when we reheated it. Cannolis had pistachios on one end and chocolate chips on the other--perfection. You can tell that they care about their food and we will definitely be back.

We tried a salad, bruschetta,pizza, tiramisu. Everything was delicious. The owner and staff were welcoming and friendly. Small "homey" space-, felt like eating at nonna's kitchen table. If you are in the area, it is a must try!

Love this place. Quick, authentic pies. Good prices. The dude who works there is always nice. Just wish they were open more.

Excellent pizzas! Great char and fresh ingredients. Service was friendly and you can't beat the speed of a super hot oven

Great Neapolitan Pizza and friendly staff. Sal has a true passion for old world Italian pizza, breads and more. Highly recommend you stop by and give them a try!!! They also have a wood fired pizza trailer and catering as well.

Delicious panini with prosciutto and mortadella ! You must try it ! The sour dough bread is best I ever had. Thanks so much for your authentic Italian food

You can taste the quality ingredients and the love put into the pizza in the first bite. This little pizza shop in a rather inconspicuous strip mall blew away all expectations. The inside of the shop is beautifully designed with an amazing mural. You can see them baking the pizzas just behind the counter. The fresh sourdough crust is amazing, as are the garlic knots. Kind staff, great food, amazing ingredients; what more could you ask?

Fantastic pizza and knots! The sourdough is divine. I highly recommend trying this place if you appreciate unique food and authentic charm with flavors that exceed your expectations. Bravo!

Walked into this place with a friend by accident glad we did they have such delicious pizza and dough. Treated us so nicely and they have a great back story and why they wanted to bring quality bread to everyone. Last part that surprised me was they broke bread with us one they where saving they wanted us to try it and they opened it up to do so. Great atmosphere, amazing food, and they care about what you eat. I don't leave reviews often.

A gem for REAL traditional Italian cooking. Fresh pasta's and amazing Dolce! A taste of Italia right here in the Ville!! Definitely go here!!!

Best real Italian wood oven pizza in Naperville. Family owned restaurant super friendly owner. Their hot honey adds the best touch to the pepperoni pizza. Pasta so fresh and delicious. Will definitely be back! Our favorite new pizza restaurant for sure

I heard great things about this place and wanted to see if it lived up to the hype! Let's just say I couldn't attach pictures because we were to busy eating the pizza! Delicious Delicious Delicious! It is a small spot so if you have anything larger then a party of 4 you may just want to do carry out. But don't let that discourage you, if you love delicious brick oven pizza, this is the spot!

Coming from a fellow first generation Italian, I can tell you with certainty that Calogero's has quality and authentic Southern Italian pizza! Their ingredients are incredibly fresh and delicious!

I love this place! Owners are very friendly and you can tell they take pride and joy in what they do. Rainbow cookies are the best thing I have ever tasted! I really love that new seasonal items pop up on the menu too. Love the pepperoni with hot honey and the pizza bianca. All delicious and no guilt given the quality of ingredients are high - organic, locally sourced or imported from Italy.

Very good pizza, we've been ordering for a while now and here I am writing a review to recognize this restaurant and their pizza as one of very good that we had over the years.

Wonderful owner, truly handmade italian pizza. Such a wonderful atmosphere and was a wonderful experience. The owner was making the pizzas and was so kind. You can see his dough starter and how clean he keeps everything and everything being handmade.

Picked up two pies. Real wood fire, you could smell the smoke in the parking lot. More New York than Napoli. Will be going back for sure.

Really great. The Neapolitan pizza is the best around. Also got the sourdough and the focaccia ( get on the mailing list ) . Really fresh and authentic.

Authentic wood-fired pizza - absolutely fantastic. The sausage was really amazing. One tip: Pizzas come in just one size, and they are fairly small compared to less authentic pizzeria standards (1 pizza feeds 1-2). So plan ahead accordingly if you're ordering for a big family like ours. This is a great addition to Naperville.

Absolutely amazing pizza and probably the best in Naperville. We ordered the margarita, funghi, and Nutella calzone and we were blown away. Highly, highly recommend!

Delicious. Pizza was great. Crust fantastic. Also had the penne a la vodka which was very tasty. Nice little place. Wanted to go to a local wood fire pizza place and Calogero's did not let us down. Talked to the owner & his daughter. He's legit Sicilian & it shows in the pizza. We'll be back.

We've been to Calogero's a number of times and have never been disappointed in the food or service. Ownership is awesome, ingredients are fresh and flavorful. This time we ordered bruschetta with our pizza( one pepperoni one sausage) and everything was fantastic especially the bruschetta! What treat! We'll be back again and again!

I have traveled all over the United States in my military career and as a native of Brooklyn NY, pizza is extremely hard to impress me with .. until I went to Calogero's .. not only was the hospitality, the family history inside of the restaurant mesmerizing.... But the Pizza.... OOOOMYGOODNESS! .. it brought NYC PIZZA back to my taste buds!! By far the BEST Pizza I have tasted in years! I will surely be returning in my travels!! And I recommend to anyone reading this.. you have to try this Pizza! Bravo Zulu Calogero's!!

Authentic Scicillian pasta and pizza in a small but "chill" location. BYOB allows patron to pair food with Chianti or Super Tuscan.

Amazingly delicious pizzas. My husband had the pepperoni and I had the BBQ chicken. Crust was perfect mixture of chewy and crispy. Enough seating for 10 in the dining room - but it was empty on a Thursday evening, and it shouldn't be!

This place is awesome! Pizza is great wood burning oven. If you like the wood burning true Italian style pizza then check this place out.

Quick and great service every time. The quality of food is amazing and taste is as well, you can't go wrong with Calogero's

Absolutely phenomenal food!! We've been to parties catered by Calogero's and their service and food was outstanding!!!

Delicios Old World Italian Pizza - Great hospitality and service!!!