Lacey T.
Yelp
Carlucci's is located next to my favorite SLC shop, Caputo's, and while I've recently found myself there nearly weekly, had not yet managed to make my way in to Carlucci's. This is no doubt due to the myriad sweets and sandwiches available at their neighbor, and while you certainly should always (ALWAYS) stop by Caputo's, Carlucci's deserved some attention prior to now. Ah well, better late than never!
It is a smallish space, but they have decent seating available inside, and while the focus appears to be the baked goods, they also offer café-style meals such as sandwiches, salads, and soup. Paired with local Café Ibis coffee and a pleasant sun-streamed interior, I could see this being a nice spot to spend some time working or with friends.
Mismatched old-fashioned plates and bowls charmingly displayed the many sweets in the pastry case, ranging from cookies, bars and brownies to tarts, cakes, and pastries, flan, and breads. They even have dog biscuits!
I kept it simple and chose a cellophane wrapped slice of chocolate cake with chocolate frosting, and black and white cookie. The cake was fine, good even, but nothing extraordinary. The cookie was a surprise delight: tender, with firm, but not too hard icing, the chocolate side very rich, the white tinged with a pleasing touch of lemon.
Parking in the area is not great, though fine during less popular times. Otherwise, you may have to hunt for a spot along the street and trek a bit. Prices are average.
The experience would have been quite positive, save for the lackluster assistance I received from a near surly young woman who did little to hide her dissatisfaction at the injustice of serving me, and my interruption of her snack time. If I had dined in that would have knocked them down to three stars, but as my interaction was limited, I will give them the benefit of the doubt, and hope this was a one-time/bad day sort of situation.
TL;DR-Not an amazing bakery, but above average.