Carnegie Diner & Cafe

Great service. Generous portions. Moldy vents. Everyone from the host to the water boy were on the ball. It's like a noisy dance where everyone knows their part and navigates the crowd perfectly. The food was generous and well made. I was amazed at the quick delivery. I like my eggs scrambled soft and they were perfect. Looks like quite a bit more than the 3 eggs I ordered. The bacon was a huge pile of strips and perfectly done. My wife raved about the Eggs Benedict. I sneezed and my wife asked for my phone and took a picture of this moldy-looking vent. I spent over $90 for breakfast. Clean your vents. And we're done.

I have lived down the block from this place for 5 years. It's always packed and on weekends has lines out the door. Easy to understand why. The food is consistently great. It's an upscale diner without upscale charges. I wanted pancakes on my most recent trip and this more than delivered. The pancakes were light and fluffy with a hint of sweetness, but not so much. A drizzle of maple syrup (organic!) elevated. French fries were crisp and seasoned and coffee came out quickly. Service staff is attentive. I got there just before 9:00 on a Sunday morning and was seated fairly quickly for a table of one. I did not feel rushed and loved watching other diner goers revel at their food.

Fabulous dinner at this cute diner. They sell a whole host of foods all day long. Nothing is too much trouble and the portion sizes are generous. The fries are crispy coated beautifully and taste super yummy. We will definitely return before we go home.

The Greek salad without lettuce was amazing. There are great people in the kitchen and Greek people out front. Great spot for food. They were very attentive about allergies. Their fish has no egg in it so that is nice. I highly recommend this place. My wife had the huge chicken club. A two handed meal.

Great location conveniently located in midtown near a bunch of hotels and other tourist attractions. I came here at about 7:30 a.m. on a Tuesday and surprisingly they were not that busy and I was able to get seated right away. The menu is extensive and there are lots of good options. But I ordered the traditional Nova lox and it was incredible. There was a good amount of smoked salmon and Asian horse amount of cream cheese on the bagel as well. It was extremely flavorful, high quality and very filling. If you are looking for a deli with lots of food options and really good portions, this is the place to go in midtown.

This place is a great diner! 🍴 Carnegie Diner & Cafe serves an endless variety of delicious 🤤 dishes 🍽️ - definitely get the Peter's Special (a 1lbs meat 🍖 sandwich 🥪), Pasta 🍝, and Apple 🍎 Pie! 🥧 The service is quick ⏲️, staff 👨‍🍳 is friendly, and they have plenty of indoor seating.🪑 I wish I came here more often!

STUNNING.... We found this by accident and it was the best find so far. The diner is super clean and tidy with the staff very polite, welcoming and attentive. Our server Christiana is an absolute asset to the diner and was very helpful. An extensive menu which is very competitively priced - see the picture of the New York Strip Steak for under $40.....😳 and free re-fills....👏 The food was amazing and you can people watch as you done - what's not to like about this place?? Fantastic experience.....Thank You

The food and Christiana service was amazing! Everyone was so welcoming, I was able to receive my drink and food right away after ordering it. The flavors was in every bite, and I’m happy to say I’m able to leave here with a happy full stomach. Drinks: Prohibition sweet and strong | sip wisely Spicy Margarita spicy but not acidic | a 9/10 margarita