Steve Lewin
Google
Was in the area with my son and decided to try this place for the first time, we had heard from a couple of people that said the food was pretty decent. Now, let me preface this by saying I was raised in Chicago and worked at several places there (and two here) that served Chicago style food (including pizza).
The atmosphere definitely has a Chicago vibe, it smells like a typical sports bar, has a bunch of TVs with various sports. I imagine this place would be packed during a Bears or Cubs/White Sox game!
The menu has a lot of options, including several Chicago staples such as pizza (both thin and deep dish), Vienna beef hot dogs, and Italian beef sandwiches. When I saw the pictures of the hotdog on the menu and on the website I have to admit I was excited and looking forward to trying them.
To give an honest review, My son and I decided to get two Chicago hot dogs as an appetizer and an “authentic“ thin crust pizza with Italian sausage.
First the hot dogs, while they did come on the prerequisite poppyseed bun with a Vienna beef sausage, the overall preparation and taste earned it 2 out of 5 stars for us. The poppyseed buns were hard as though they had been toasted, but the temperature was lukewarm at best. Everybody knows if you want an authentic Chicago hot dog, the poppyseed buns should be steamed and soft. As a result of the hard buns, it split at the bottom after taking the first bite causing all the toppings to fall through onto the plate. Yes they did have the bright green relish, diced onions and tomatoes. We opted for no sport pepper, and there was a smattering of celery salt on the dogs. There was no pickle spear or yellow mustard on the dogs! Although there was a bottle of yellow mustard hiding behind the large ketchup bottle on the table, who serves an authentic Chicago hot dog with no mustard or pickle spears? I’m not sure why, but they also put two packets of mayonnaise on the plate? My honest opinion of the hot dogs? If you want truly authentic good tasting hot dogs, make them at home yourself or wait for the Portillo’s to open in Kennesaw sometime in November. All too often I have learned if you can’t do a Chicago hot dog right, your Italian beef is likely going to miss the mark as well.
Now for the “authentic” thin crust pizza. First let me say, I really wanted to like it, but the honest truth is I would never order it again. I asked for the pizza to be slightly well done so that the cheese was golden brown and the crust crispy without being burnt. While they did cook it properly so the cheese was browned, the crust was soft/floppy and far from crispy. Honestly, the crust tasted like it was premade/frozen. My biggest disappointment was the Italian sausage topping. If you’re looking for authentic Chicago Italian sausage, this is not the place unless you like frozen Italian sausage chunks that tastes like they came straight out of a Pizza Hut restaurant. If you know your Chicago pizza, then you know that Italian sausage should be chunked, fresh if possible, and have a distinct hint of fennel as though you emptied the casing of an Italian sausage link from the store or bought it in bulk and parsed it out evenly on the pizza. This sausage honestly tasted like frozen breakfast sausage. I give it one out of five stars only because they cut it in squares. Although they offer deep dish pizza, if they can’t do thin crust properly, I’m hesitant to try the deep dish. If you want an authentic Chicago thin crust or deep dish/stuffed pizza experience, you have several much better options around the metro area such as Nancy’s and even Rosati’s.
To be fair, the service was good, the waitress was attentive and checked on us regularly. It’s not her fault if the meal didn’t turn out as expected.
Overall, if you’re looking for a place to hang out with friends and watch a game and have some respectable bar food, this place is great, but if you’re looking for a truly authentic “Chicago food” experience, I’m sorry to say this place did not quite live up to its name for us on two of the most iconic Chicago items.