Sam T.
Yelp
I've never been to its owner's other restaurants, but we stopped in to Ciao after seeing some positive posts about it online, and I definitely want to come back and try more.
It was -- as to be expected -- very uncrowded when we visited at around 3:30 on a Sunday afternoon. We got greeted and seated quickly.
Our server, whose name I unfortunately have forgotten, was lovely and attentive. She was great with suggestions and definitely wanted to make sure she answered any questions we had about the menu.
Our server highly recommended the bruschetta, which I look forward to trying, but we skipped it this visit because my spouse isn't a fan of uncooked tomatoes. He ordered the spaghetti with meat sauce, while I -- a gnocchi lover -- went with the gnocchi alla romana.
We were pleasantly surprised to find that our orders came with a salad, which was nice and fresh. The serving size is on the smaller side, which I don't mind at all when it's coming as a complement to a main dish, but I wanted to mention for folks used to big servings. I thought the house dressing was delicious.
For the pasta dishes: first off, the servings are generous. Not "this is absurdly, ridiculously big for one human even with the most voracious appetite" big the way that some places get but "I could split this into two servings and be fine" big, which is what I prefer. (That being said...as you'll see, I cleaned my plate this visit!) My husband liked his spaghetti and gave it the detailed review of "it's good". Not a world changer maybe, but tasty. He took about half home.
Now, let's talk about my dish. I will say that it's nothing like any gnocchi alla romana I've come across before; typically, I encounter that dish as a semolina-based gnocchi that's baked. This is the gnocchi that most people here think of as "standard" -- made with potatoes and cooked, I believe, in water.
Now with that aside, this dish is absolutely delicious. The gnocchi are great; they are tender, not tough. What it's served in -- a mix of tomatoes, capers, mozzarella, and basil -- is absolute perfection. The first bite was so surprisingly delicious I think I said a curse word out loud. (OK, I know I did.) It's the perfect balance of flavors with the hearty gnocchi, fresh produce, and a slight tang from the capers. This is my favorite gnocchi dish I've had in the city and one of my favorites in general. I was full about halfway through my plate but kept going because I didn't want the flavor to stop. So yeah, absolute perfection.
The bread that came with our pasta was good! I do wish the butter had been served in a dish and a little less cold rather than in the butter packets, but that's not a huge deal.
I ended up getting dessert to-go; I went with the server's recommendation of a new cookie crumble banana cheesecake. When I ate it later, it was delicious! Flavorful but not super dense and heavy.
Super subjective sidebar that I don't factor into this rating: I'm not personally a huge fan of the overall decor style -- and that'll obviously vary a lot from person to person! But it's definitely a lot of gray in the "modern farmhouse" inspiration. I wouldn't personally call this a "cozy" restaurant as a result. But again, people like different things! I just wouldn't go here if I really wanted the candlelit vibes some people associate with Italian restaurants in general and that I get in the mood for sometimes. And sound, at least when it's uncrowded, echos a bit here.
Now, one final big positive: the price. For two soft drinks, two big servings of pasta with salads and bread, and one dessert, the total before tip was $55. I felt like we really, really got our money's worth.
I saw several folks walking out with pizzas to go, so I look forward to giving one a try. But honestly, I feel like I'm going to need that gnocchi dish every time I'm nearby.