Olivia R.
Yelp
I have never, ever written a Yelp review in my life. However, I just left City Island Pizza Company, and I feel inspired -- NO, compelled to write this review. And here's what I have to say. I have lived in New York City for 35 years, and I've eaten pizza in every borough, in every neighborhood, (except Staten Island). City Island Pizza Company served me possibly the greatest slice of pizza I have ever had. It was tremendous. It is the perfect slice. The tomato sauce, perfection. The cheese -- soft, but not too soft, stays together and melted in my mouth. This crust should be studied. So thin, yet has a chew with a bite. The sauce and cheese were in harmony. This might be the best pizza place in New York City. Thank you, City Island Pizza Company!
Not to mention the customer service was terrific. The girl at the counter was a real sweetheart.