Marie S.
Yelp
Addendum from one of the friends:
I'm 100% in agreement with Marie's original review. When we paid our first visit to Cloak & Dagger in the summer, we wondered whether its ambiance would be improved by visiting during the winter when the weather was a little more suited to the cocktail bar's dark academia vibe. I returned to Cloak & Dagger in December, though, and I have to say that my review is not any more positive--if anything, my opinion of Cloak & Dagger got worse on second visit.
First, the positives: the bartenders, once again, were the highlight of my experience. They were knowledgeable, friendly, and very attentive. My boyfriend and I visited while the Advanced Potion Making menu was being offered, which featured cocktails inspired by potions from the Harry Potter series. We tried the Amortentia (light, refreshing, not too sweet); the Draught of Living Death (smoky and unsurprisingly boozy); and the Polyjuice Potion (quite sweet and surprisingly boozy). Positive reviews all around on the cocktails. We also tried the Sharp Cheddar Mac and the Bangers and Mash, both of which we enjoyed. Cloak & Dagger is a solid option if you're looking for good vegan food in Cleveland!
Unfortunately, the atmosphere still left something to be desired. The loud party music once again made the vibe less swanky and more dive bar. On top of that, while we were still eating our food the host came over and gave us a twenty minute warning on our reservation. I understand that it's a popular place and Cloak & Dagger has to honor the schedule, however there were several open seats when we were asked to leave, which was pretty off-putting. We had been planning to order a couple more cocktails and were disappointed that we were pushed out and didn't get a chance to try them.
Cloak & Dagger has so much potential. There is clearly a lot of thought and creativity put into designing their menus and the drinks are good; the atmosphere, however, doesn't cut it. A few easy fixes-- changing the music, maybe just a tad more lighting, and not rushing guests--would make the experience so much better. As it is, Cloak & Dagger doesn't live up to the hype.